What to say about Sunshine Cleaning...well, it’s not Little Miss Sunshine 2, which I’m afraid a lot of people who are coming to see it this weekend are thinking it’s going to be. It’s not being billed as a follow-up to the 2006 Best Pitcure nominee, but it has enough in common with the earlier picture to trade on both its quality and its success. It is, however, being billed as a comedy, which is somewhat disingenuous because comedies are funny and this movie isn’t; it’s not entirely devoid of humor, but what humor there is takes up all of about two minutes and thirty seconds (and it’s no coincidence that that’s about how long your average movie trailer is).
The rest of the not quite two hours is sort of a study in various forms of self-pity, and to say that the material is dark is to understate things a bit. It certainly tries to be funny, and there is a solid cast of characters (in the metaphorical sense); but quirky ensemble putting on a black comedy is Coen Brothers territory, and they have set the bar so high that most other attempts at the form - including Sunshine Cleaning - wind up looking like cheap imitations.
See...there’s Rose (Amy Adams), a single mother who doesn’t make enough money working as a maid - she cleans the houses of her classmates from the high school cheerleading days, all of whom apparently majored in gold-digging - to put her son through private school. Why does the son need private school? Seems that the administrators at the public school have wearied of the little boy’s increasingly bizarre pattern of behavior, including a spate of licking that culminated with him licking the teacher’s leg. So Rose gets a tip, from ex-boyfriend turned cop Mac (Steve Zahn, who appears to be on the Roger Clemens “workout” program), who is married to someone else but is still bagging Rose on the side, that she should go into crime scene cleanup, a potentially lucrative field experiencing a growth phase.
She ropes her sister Norah (Emily Blunt, wearing a lot of the things that Axl Rose apparently chose not to wear in the video for “Welcome To The Jungle”) into the fray, which is convenient because Norah can’t keep a job for very long and needs money in order to...well, buy eyeliner, I suppose. Also, because with only one girl, the scene where they take the mattress out to the dumpster would not have been as funny. Now, as these two dynamic bringers of light to the dark times in people’s lives find out, you can’t just dispose of biohazards in the dumpster. Actual quote from the movie: “Who knew?” But, with hard work and a bit of luck, they get better at what they do...and they grow as people...and they get in touch with their inner demons.
The girls have had a hard time over the years coping with the death of their mother, by suicide, when they were very young - old enough to understand what had happened, but too young to understand why. Some of the best scenes in the movie have Norah and Rose’s son Oscar trying in their own ways to make sense of death: Norah goes “trestling" (climbing the support posts of a train trestle all the way to the top and hanging there while the train passes) and thinks about death as the train hurtles by, and Rose’s son Oscar uses a CB radio to try talk to whatever god he made up to make himself feel less insecure about being alive. There’s a lot of existential potential in those scenes, but they are brief and the potential is wasted.
The filmmakers might have taken the road less traveled, down philosophical and expository paths, giving these two talented actresses a real chance to flex their chops; but instead, they referred to their film school Screenwriting 101 notebooks and invented a major crisis to force all the little crises to a head (sometimes this is called a “climax”) and then tied up all of the loose ends (except for the interesting cleaning supplies salesman who also builds model airplanes and only has one arm) into a neat little ball that is supposed to make you feel all warm and fuzzy inside (sometimes this is called “falling action”). And would you honestly believe that they work a cute little kitten into the ending, so as to all but ensure that warm, fuzzy feeling?
It’s such a crappy third act that if David Fincher had directed it and cast Brad PItt as the guy with one arm, you can bet it would be up for about half a dozen Oscars next year, including Best Visual Effects, just for making Brad’s arm disappear. If this film had actually been a comedy, the third act might have worked, even with the kitten included; but it just never got its funny legs under the morbid center of its dark, dramatic heart. Ultimately, it plays like a movie that isn’t sure if it wants to be serious or funny, and winds up spending so much time trying to be a bit of both that it never manages to do either one very well for very long.
Sunday, March 29, 2009
Monday, March 23, 2009
Moscow, Belgium (#2)
Well, Chuck, he’s a boorish lout who drives a truck and wants to avoid involving the police when he has a fender bender, and she’s a mother of three who’s letting her husband sleep with someone half his age because she’s sure he’ll come back eventually. Let’s give a warm welcome to Johnny and Matty!
Moscow, Belgium is the story of two people who have been beaten almost all the way down, either by the world or by their own choices - you make the call! Of course, there’s an irony here, too, of sorts: if not for those choices that have beaten them down, their initial interaction after a parkig lot fender bender could not have happened the way that it did, and they never would have had the chance to know each other the way they wound up knowing each other.
Is it love, ultimately? Again...you make the call! It looks like it at first, then there’s a blowout, and sort of a reconciliation by the end. But hey now, wait, damnit, you’re spoiling it! Maybe, but you’re not going to watch it anyway. There are exactly two people I know of who read this blog that might wind up seeing this picture - and I’d say that the chances are about 75% that one or both of them will have seen it by the time they read this post. Most of the rest will not have heard of it - and probably wouldn’t see it anyway, ‘cause it ain’t in American.
Doesn’t need to be, either, and not because love is universal, or any fluffy romantic nonsense like that. For the first couple of acts, you can pretty much get what they’re saying just by watching the way they say it. No one’s trying to forge peace in the Middle East or make sense of a government bailout program here - it’s just two people who meet by chance, in a way that is not conducive to a budding friendship, never mind the possibility of eventually bumping uglies.
And yet that friendship manages to emerge, and it does so because the two characters are lonely, trapped in their own lives, so far removed from the dreams of youth that they’ve not only put their dreams on the back burner, they’ve turned off the stove and don’t even bother getting up to go into the kitchen very much anymore. You can see that loneliness in their eyes, in the crushing air of fatigue that they wear like an IV drip, in the tedium of daily tasks repeated over and over and over again.
There’s nothing special about watching two unlikely friends take the first steps in that unlikely friendship. What’s unique about Moscow, Belgium is its authenticity. Matty screams at Johnny in the parking lot after the fender bender because she’s got a lot of pent-up frustration, and when she tells him that he’s blind to the world up there in the cab of his truck, she means it one way and he takes it in a completely different way. Later, he shows up at her apartment to fix the trunk of her car, and her kids shout down from the balcony, aganist mom’s wishes, to tell him which car is hers. Matty wants nothing to do with him, but he manages to fix her car - so she invites him to stay for dinner. As the film progresses, the excellent screenplay fills in the details as the characters get to know each other.
Only the climactic scene in (and then out in front of) the pub near the end of the film feels forced and a little convoluted; everything else is organic and true (and by the end, you can almost imagine that the convoluted pub scene might just have been necessary after all), bolstered by excellent pacing in the direction and tremendous acting by Barbara Sarafian and Jurgen Delnaet, as Matty and Johnny, respectively.
Moscow, Belgium is not an especially challenging film, but it is an immensely satisfying one, a real art film in what is, anymore, a sea of mid-major adaptations of obscure novels. It’s beautiful and charming in such amazingly unexpected ways. Don’t let the goofy-looking one-sheet fool you (that is not, in fact, Chris Elliott with red hair) - this one’s a winner.
Moscow, Belgium is the story of two people who have been beaten almost all the way down, either by the world or by their own choices - you make the call! Of course, there’s an irony here, too, of sorts: if not for those choices that have beaten them down, their initial interaction after a parkig lot fender bender could not have happened the way that it did, and they never would have had the chance to know each other the way they wound up knowing each other.
Is it love, ultimately? Again...you make the call! It looks like it at first, then there’s a blowout, and sort of a reconciliation by the end. But hey now, wait, damnit, you’re spoiling it! Maybe, but you’re not going to watch it anyway. There are exactly two people I know of who read this blog that might wind up seeing this picture - and I’d say that the chances are about 75% that one or both of them will have seen it by the time they read this post. Most of the rest will not have heard of it - and probably wouldn’t see it anyway, ‘cause it ain’t in American.
Doesn’t need to be, either, and not because love is universal, or any fluffy romantic nonsense like that. For the first couple of acts, you can pretty much get what they’re saying just by watching the way they say it. No one’s trying to forge peace in the Middle East or make sense of a government bailout program here - it’s just two people who meet by chance, in a way that is not conducive to a budding friendship, never mind the possibility of eventually bumping uglies.
And yet that friendship manages to emerge, and it does so because the two characters are lonely, trapped in their own lives, so far removed from the dreams of youth that they’ve not only put their dreams on the back burner, they’ve turned off the stove and don’t even bother getting up to go into the kitchen very much anymore. You can see that loneliness in their eyes, in the crushing air of fatigue that they wear like an IV drip, in the tedium of daily tasks repeated over and over and over again.
There’s nothing special about watching two unlikely friends take the first steps in that unlikely friendship. What’s unique about Moscow, Belgium is its authenticity. Matty screams at Johnny in the parking lot after the fender bender because she’s got a lot of pent-up frustration, and when she tells him that he’s blind to the world up there in the cab of his truck, she means it one way and he takes it in a completely different way. Later, he shows up at her apartment to fix the trunk of her car, and her kids shout down from the balcony, aganist mom’s wishes, to tell him which car is hers. Matty wants nothing to do with him, but he manages to fix her car - so she invites him to stay for dinner. As the film progresses, the excellent screenplay fills in the details as the characters get to know each other.
Only the climactic scene in (and then out in front of) the pub near the end of the film feels forced and a little convoluted; everything else is organic and true (and by the end, you can almost imagine that the convoluted pub scene might just have been necessary after all), bolstered by excellent pacing in the direction and tremendous acting by Barbara Sarafian and Jurgen Delnaet, as Matty and Johnny, respectively.
Moscow, Belgium is not an especially challenging film, but it is an immensely satisfying one, a real art film in what is, anymore, a sea of mid-major adaptations of obscure novels. It’s beautiful and charming in such amazingly unexpected ways. Don’t let the goofy-looking one-sheet fool you (that is not, in fact, Chris Elliott with red hair) - this one’s a winner.
Sunday, March 22, 2009
Four Seasons Restaurant
We had the chance to have brunch this afternoon because I didn’t have to go in to work until two, so we rolled by Four Seasons Restaurant on Shadeland Avenue, just south of 21st Street. Had there been an emphasis on pancakes, this might well have been a carbon copy of the Blueberry Hill Pancake House, which occupies a former Perkins space on East Washington Street, near I-465. The décor - pastels and formica - is the same, and the staff appeared interchangeable, right down to the ethnic-looking fellow who leaned on a counter and just seemed to be watching everything.
Amy started with lemon chicken rice soup, which came out looking thick and opaque, though she said it was pretty good. Ever the geek for Greek, she went for the gyro sandwich, which came out exactly like you expect a gyro to come out - quite a lot of roasted lamb and beef rolled in pita bread with tomatoes, onions, and tzaziki on the side. This one was so full that she had to eat it with a fork, and the meat had the rich, aromatic flavor that good gyro meat should have - though I’ll be a coal miner’s daughter if it’s actually prepared in house.
I had a ham and Swiss omelette with onions (hash browns and whole wheat toast on the side), which was perfectly adequate without being at all remarkable. The Swiss cheese, unfortunately, was the processed cheese with “Swiss flavor” - a bush league move that was pretty disappointing. Pasteurized process cheese food has no place in any resepctable restaurant; but then again, this is not the kind of place that aspires to greatness.
Places like Four Seasons and Blueberry Hill Pancake House are perfectly fine if you want something simple and if you don’t mind eating where your food is just assembled, rather than prepared. It’s one of those places that you try once to see what it’s like, and you realize about halfway through your meal that there’s just no good reason ever to come back. It’s not that it’s actively bad - it’s just that there’s nothing you can get here that you can’t better at one of a half dozen or so other places in town.
Amy started with lemon chicken rice soup, which came out looking thick and opaque, though she said it was pretty good. Ever the geek for Greek, she went for the gyro sandwich, which came out exactly like you expect a gyro to come out - quite a lot of roasted lamb and beef rolled in pita bread with tomatoes, onions, and tzaziki on the side. This one was so full that she had to eat it with a fork, and the meat had the rich, aromatic flavor that good gyro meat should have - though I’ll be a coal miner’s daughter if it’s actually prepared in house.
I had a ham and Swiss omelette with onions (hash browns and whole wheat toast on the side), which was perfectly adequate without being at all remarkable. The Swiss cheese, unfortunately, was the processed cheese with “Swiss flavor” - a bush league move that was pretty disappointing. Pasteurized process cheese food has no place in any resepctable restaurant; but then again, this is not the kind of place that aspires to greatness.
Places like Four Seasons and Blueberry Hill Pancake House are perfectly fine if you want something simple and if you don’t mind eating where your food is just assembled, rather than prepared. It’s one of those places that you try once to see what it’s like, and you realize about halfway through your meal that there’s just no good reason ever to come back. It’s not that it’s actively bad - it’s just that there’s nothing you can get here that you can’t better at one of a half dozen or so other places in town.
Saturday, March 21, 2009
Moscow, Belgium (#1)
Stop what you're doing, right this second, and go see Moscow, Belgium. Seriously. You probably only have a week, and who knows if you'll ever get around to adding it to your Netflix queue? Go, get a couple of beers (May I suggest the Beer of the Month, Leinenkugel's Classic Amber?), and have a go at this remarkable little film.
Friday, March 20, 2009
Jonathan Demme And Jenny Lumet On Rachel Getting Married
I was listening to NPR's Fresh Air on the way to work today and caught part of an interview with director Jonathan Demme and screenwriter Jenny Lumet, who worked together on last year's remarkable Rachel Getting Married. The interview originally aired back in October, but this was the first time I heard it. I didn't catch the whole thing, but you can listen to it on Fresh Air's website here. Two of the things they touched on were the use of handheld cameras (which caused a lot of problems when we played the film) and the dishwasher loading competition, which apparently had its roots in Lumet's childhood, when her dad and director Bob Fosse got into an argument after dinner at Lumet's house one night and then spent an hour and a half loading and unloading the dishwasher.
I'm posting this at work and don't want to spend too much time on it, so I'll come back to it later and add links - because I just know that you're dying for more things to click in my posts.
I'm posting this at work and don't want to spend too much time on it, so I'll come back to it later and add links - because I just know that you're dying for more things to click in my posts.
Monday, March 16, 2009
Chin National Day 2009 - Pictures And Links
So it took practically a month, but here are some pictures from Chin National Day 2009, along with a link to the website of the Chin People Of Indianapolis, which contains lots of other links to various information and resources concerning the Burmese refugees who are here in Indianapolis and the people of Chin State generally. Though not top five, one of the better non-fiction books I read last year was called The Iron Road: A Stand For Truth And Democracy In Burma, by James Mawdsley, an English fellow who did time - literally - in Burma for advocating freedom and attempting to petition the "government," on behalf of the Burmese people, for a redress of grievances. Last but not least is a link to a documentary I just read about today at work, called Burma VJ, a Danish film which doesn't release theatrically until 2010 but is currently doing the festival circuit, both in the United States and abroad.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
New Photos #3
Okay, at long last here are some recent photos of Jackson. The first set just has a few photos of Jackson mugging for the camera, chewing on a hat, and playing in a big cardboard box. Buy all the toys you want for your little critters, and they'll still wind up having the most fun with empty cardboard cartons and big stacks of Pizza Express cups. The second set is from one part of an excellent walk along the downtown canal last month. (The largest part of why there have been so few new photos of Jackson is that we did not get out and about much on Sunday afternoons this winter because Jackson tended to get very cranky very quickly, a situation that does not make for good times out on the town. On this particular day, however, he was in excellent spirits, and we walked a considerable amont of the Canal Walk.) The final set is also part of the walk on the canal. When we walked by the State Museum, Jackson became very interested in the giant mastodont statues just off the sidewalk outside the museum, and he walked over the pebbly gravel and around among them long enough for me to get quite a few pictures. Hopefully, as the weather gets nicer and there are more chances to get out and about, there will be more opportunities to get pictures of Jackson exploring the world.
Wednesday, March 04, 2009
One...One New Photo! (And A New Computer)
No, really, there are lots and lots of photos from Chin National Day - I just haven't sorted through all of them yet. Also, I was about a week and a half basically disconnected from the Interwebs because of a dying modem. I got a new computer, though, and I'm pretty close to caught up. When I was going through the photos, this one of Jackson made me laugh out loud.

And here's what that new computer looks like:

Among other things, it has not escaped my attention that: an overrated piece of crap won Best Picture; Bobby Jindal made the Republicans look even more ridiculous (the second "rising star" to do so for the GOP in as many tries); the Colts failed to use any of the cap money saved by cutting Marvin Harrison on signing Albert Haynesworth; and that the men's Hoosiers may well post their worst season since World War I. That I have not commented on any of those things has less to do with whether or not they are interesting than with the fact that it's difficult to do much of anything else on the Internets when you're trying to download a 367 megabyte system update with a dial-up modem.

And here's what that new computer looks like:

Among other things, it has not escaped my attention that: an overrated piece of crap won Best Picture; Bobby Jindal made the Republicans look even more ridiculous (the second "rising star" to do so for the GOP in as many tries); the Colts failed to use any of the cap money saved by cutting Marvin Harrison on signing Albert Haynesworth; and that the men's Hoosiers may well post their worst season since World War I. That I have not commented on any of those things has less to do with whether or not they are interesting than with the fact that it's difficult to do much of anything else on the Internets when you're trying to download a 367 megabyte system update with a dial-up modem.
Monday, February 23, 2009
Chin National Day 2009
Somewhere back there in the blog logs I made mention of Chin National Day, a day set aside by the people of Chin State in the southeast Asian country of Burma - “you may know it as Myanmar...but it will always be Burma to me” - to commemorate “national unity, [and] simple truths of freedom, equality, and self-determination.” February 20th, 1948, was the day on which the people of Chin State - located in western Burma - rose up to demand their independence from the British. The Chin people continue to celebrate the anniversary of this important day in their history, and the people of Indiana - particularly on the south side, in Perry Township - are fortunate to have one of the largest populations of Burmese refugees of any city in the United States.
So...after Jackson had his nap Saturday afternoon, we bundled him up and headed down to the Perry Meridian Academy, which is attached to Perry Meridian Middle School, which is down on the south side on the northwest corner of 135 and Stop 11 (although technically I think Stop 11 changes names once you get west of 135). Their gym was packed, almost entirely with Burmese people, and so many of them were happy and smiling and clearly having a very good time. We got into the gym just as the speeches part of the afternoon was ending, so we didn’t stay in our seats for very long. People started clearing out, and we made our way to the cafeteria, where traditional food from Burma was being served.
Amy had a bowl of noodles with bits of hard-boiled egg in a light chicken broth, and I had a bowl of hominy and tripe (yes...tripe) in a thin broth of indeterminate origin. Each bowl also contained a deep-fried, salty cornbread dumpling. Served with these soups was a little bowl with salt, wedges of lime, and a small amount of an extremely spicy seasoning that contained chiles, lemongrass, and cilantro. Say what you will about people from Southeast Asia - they don’t screw around when it comes to heat in their food. The tripe was interesting at first - the texture was something akin to calamari, and it tasted vaguely of beef - but I found Amy’s bowl of noodles and hard-boiled egg more enjoyable in the end. The cornbread dumplings were very good, and the chile mixture (not pictured) was very good - though exremely spicy and not for the faint of heart.


We repaired back to the gym after we ate and were treated to a fashion show consisting of girls in elaborate dresses and boys in fancy sport coats parading up and down the stage; a dance in which the girls got to display some fancy footwork as they danced around and over a series of long poles that boys, situated at each end, were tapping rhythmically on the floor; and finally some wrestling, where the two opponents each had to take hold of a belt worn by the other and attempt to effect a takedown. Unfortunately, each takedown brought cheers and whistles from the sizable crowd, and all the noise scared poor little Jackson, so we had to beat a hasty retreat before the wrestling got too far along.
It was a little bit hot and cramped in the gym, with that many people, but it was still a lot of fun. I took about a million pictures, but my modem isn’t working and playing well with others and my Internet connection has been sketchy for the last couple of weeks, so I may not be able to post the pictures until I pick up my new laptop and get it set up and connected to the Interwebs on Monday night. However, I can post a link to a recent story in Poets & Writers magazine, about the state of literature in Burma; it's not a pretty picture. On a short list of the poorest countries with the most oppressed people on Earth, Burma would be at or near the top. Every word of every page of printed matter in Burma must be approved by government censors. There can be no defense of a such a policy, nor of an illegitimate faux governmental entity that supports such a policy. Quite a lot of Burmese people shook my hand and thanked me for coming to the Chin National Day celebration on Saturday - but we are the ones who should be thanking them, for having the courage still to smile, and to share their culture with the uncultured people of Indiana, who desperately need all the lessons they can get in diversity and tolerance.
And we can hope that humanity will continue to evolve, to the point that eventually the pox that is conservative thinking will be exterminated. Only then will freedom ring, and perhaps one day Myanmar will become Burma once again.
So...after Jackson had his nap Saturday afternoon, we bundled him up and headed down to the Perry Meridian Academy, which is attached to Perry Meridian Middle School, which is down on the south side on the northwest corner of 135 and Stop 11 (although technically I think Stop 11 changes names once you get west of 135). Their gym was packed, almost entirely with Burmese people, and so many of them were happy and smiling and clearly having a very good time. We got into the gym just as the speeches part of the afternoon was ending, so we didn’t stay in our seats for very long. People started clearing out, and we made our way to the cafeteria, where traditional food from Burma was being served.
Amy had a bowl of noodles with bits of hard-boiled egg in a light chicken broth, and I had a bowl of hominy and tripe (yes...tripe) in a thin broth of indeterminate origin. Each bowl also contained a deep-fried, salty cornbread dumpling. Served with these soups was a little bowl with salt, wedges of lime, and a small amount of an extremely spicy seasoning that contained chiles, lemongrass, and cilantro. Say what you will about people from Southeast Asia - they don’t screw around when it comes to heat in their food. The tripe was interesting at first - the texture was something akin to calamari, and it tasted vaguely of beef - but I found Amy’s bowl of noodles and hard-boiled egg more enjoyable in the end. The cornbread dumplings were very good, and the chile mixture (not pictured) was very good - though exremely spicy and not for the faint of heart.


We repaired back to the gym after we ate and were treated to a fashion show consisting of girls in elaborate dresses and boys in fancy sport coats parading up and down the stage; a dance in which the girls got to display some fancy footwork as they danced around and over a series of long poles that boys, situated at each end, were tapping rhythmically on the floor; and finally some wrestling, where the two opponents each had to take hold of a belt worn by the other and attempt to effect a takedown. Unfortunately, each takedown brought cheers and whistles from the sizable crowd, and all the noise scared poor little Jackson, so we had to beat a hasty retreat before the wrestling got too far along.
It was a little bit hot and cramped in the gym, with that many people, but it was still a lot of fun. I took about a million pictures, but my modem isn’t working and playing well with others and my Internet connection has been sketchy for the last couple of weeks, so I may not be able to post the pictures until I pick up my new laptop and get it set up and connected to the Interwebs on Monday night. However, I can post a link to a recent story in Poets & Writers magazine, about the state of literature in Burma; it's not a pretty picture. On a short list of the poorest countries with the most oppressed people on Earth, Burma would be at or near the top. Every word of every page of printed matter in Burma must be approved by government censors. There can be no defense of a such a policy, nor of an illegitimate faux governmental entity that supports such a policy. Quite a lot of Burmese people shook my hand and thanked me for coming to the Chin National Day celebration on Saturday - but we are the ones who should be thanking them, for having the courage still to smile, and to share their culture with the uncultured people of Indiana, who desperately need all the lessons they can get in diversity and tolerance.
And we can hope that humanity will continue to evolve, to the point that eventually the pox that is conservative thinking will be exterminated. Only then will freedom ring, and perhaps one day Myanmar will become Burma once again.
Saturday, February 21, 2009
The Wrestler
Finally got around to seeing Darren Aronofsky’s latest picture tonight after work, and it’s got me thinking about two other pictures - Aronofsky’s own Requiem For A Dream - to which The Wrestler bears some uncanny thematic similarities - and last year’s There Will Be Blood, from P.T. Anderson, which is similar to Aronofsky’s latest in that it’s largely a showcase for one particular actor.
The story is of Randy “The Ram” Robinson (Mickey Rourke, in a role that’s probably going to win him an Oscar Sunday night), a professional wrestler who is past even the twilight of his career. Twenty years ago, he headlined Madison Square Garden in a now-legendary match against the Ayatollah - and now he’s making the rounds of east coast regional circuits and contemplating a nostalgic repeat of his classic match with the Ayatollah.
(There are echoes here of the real-life match between Hulk Hogan and the Iron Sheik from back in the eighties. Hogan won the match, and the WWF title - and thereby set the stage for the massive explosion of popularity that professional wrestling enjoyed in the late eighties and early nineties, and which it is still enjoying, to a somewhat lesser degree, today.)
Then he has a heart attack, and now it’s time to take stock of his life and finally look full in the face all of the important things he has, to varying degrees, been ignoring all his life as he tried - and failed - to make a living in the ring. This consists primarily of making peace with his estranged daughter Stephanie (Evan Rachel Wood) and making it known to the stripper, Cassidy (Marisa Tomei), he’s in love with that he is, in fact, in love with her.
All of it weighs on Randy, and Rourke brings this off brilliantly, with heavy, sad eyes, weary voice, and an air of resignation that hangs over him like a shroud. He goes through the motions of getting a job, calling on his daughter, and making awkward advances toward Cassidy; but the effort is Sisyphian, especially with respect to Stephanie. He manages to break through the space between their lives by buying her a present that Cassidy helps pick out - but then he misses a dinner date that he makes with her because he winds up partying with a girl he meets after Cassidy rejects one of his advances.
If the basic argument here sounds familiar, it’s because it’s the same thing that happened to the Jared Leto and Marlon Wayans characters in Requiem For A Dream. Their addiction was smack - Randy’s is wrestling. It’s all he is, all he knows how to be - and the cruel irony is that the heart attack didn’t kill him; instead, it damaged him just enough to make him realize that everything he gave up for wrestling is all that he has left. Unfortunately, he doesn’t know what to do with any of it, and we get to watch the inexorable pull of the ring as he runs into more and more dead ends in his post-wrestling life. (Actually, that’s not exactly true - he does know what to do with all of those things he has now instead of wrestling; he just doesn’t know how to do any of them very well.)
Much of the film plays like a documentary, which I think is due to three major factors. The first is the film’s style - grainy photography, close shots, and handheld cameras (though not nearly as pervasive - nor as jarring - as those employed in Rachel Getting Married) that foster a feeling of gritty realism. The second is the virtually complete lack of melodrama - these are just real people trying to do the best they can, and failing more often than not. None of the characters in this film have any delusions of grandeur - nor are they made to appear as though they do when they obviously do not. The third, of course, is the ghost of Rourke’s own checkered past, which includes, most importantly, a largely unrealized potential as an actor. To the extent that this film works, I don’t think it’s unfair to say that it could not have worked without someone such as Rourke playing the lead.
That being said, however, the film is not without its flaws - the ending being foremost among them. (And this from someone who was a-okay with the abrupt ending of No Country For Old Men.) It’s pretty clear what’s going to happen to Randy, but waiting there in the wings - literally - is Cassidy, who is ultimately a stronger character than Randy because she does what he is unable to do. She walks off the stage in the middle of her set and goes to see Randy in his rematch with the Ayatollah - and in doing so breaks out of the funk that has become her own life. It could be argued that Randy remains true to himself by going back to wresting, even though he knows it will probably kill him; but the self to which he remains true is an incomplete, lesser self - and he chooses to remain that lesser self, despite the fact that his efforts to rise above it are sincere, if not motivated by his own designs.
I’m not arguing that there should have been a happy ending - nor even that there should have been a more complete, which is to say resolved, ending; but I think that Cassidy gets short shrift being left in the background as Randy takes to the ring. Marisa Tomei is up for an Oscar for this role, though she won’t win; and I don’t know that an extra scene at the end, giving a sense of where her character goes next, would have been enough to win a second surprising Oscar for her - but it would have gone a long way toward making The Wrestler a more satisfying film.
The story is of Randy “The Ram” Robinson (Mickey Rourke, in a role that’s probably going to win him an Oscar Sunday night), a professional wrestler who is past even the twilight of his career. Twenty years ago, he headlined Madison Square Garden in a now-legendary match against the Ayatollah - and now he’s making the rounds of east coast regional circuits and contemplating a nostalgic repeat of his classic match with the Ayatollah.
(There are echoes here of the real-life match between Hulk Hogan and the Iron Sheik from back in the eighties. Hogan won the match, and the WWF title - and thereby set the stage for the massive explosion of popularity that professional wrestling enjoyed in the late eighties and early nineties, and which it is still enjoying, to a somewhat lesser degree, today.)
Then he has a heart attack, and now it’s time to take stock of his life and finally look full in the face all of the important things he has, to varying degrees, been ignoring all his life as he tried - and failed - to make a living in the ring. This consists primarily of making peace with his estranged daughter Stephanie (Evan Rachel Wood) and making it known to the stripper, Cassidy (Marisa Tomei), he’s in love with that he is, in fact, in love with her.
All of it weighs on Randy, and Rourke brings this off brilliantly, with heavy, sad eyes, weary voice, and an air of resignation that hangs over him like a shroud. He goes through the motions of getting a job, calling on his daughter, and making awkward advances toward Cassidy; but the effort is Sisyphian, especially with respect to Stephanie. He manages to break through the space between their lives by buying her a present that Cassidy helps pick out - but then he misses a dinner date that he makes with her because he winds up partying with a girl he meets after Cassidy rejects one of his advances.
If the basic argument here sounds familiar, it’s because it’s the same thing that happened to the Jared Leto and Marlon Wayans characters in Requiem For A Dream. Their addiction was smack - Randy’s is wrestling. It’s all he is, all he knows how to be - and the cruel irony is that the heart attack didn’t kill him; instead, it damaged him just enough to make him realize that everything he gave up for wrestling is all that he has left. Unfortunately, he doesn’t know what to do with any of it, and we get to watch the inexorable pull of the ring as he runs into more and more dead ends in his post-wrestling life. (Actually, that’s not exactly true - he does know what to do with all of those things he has now instead of wrestling; he just doesn’t know how to do any of them very well.)
Much of the film plays like a documentary, which I think is due to three major factors. The first is the film’s style - grainy photography, close shots, and handheld cameras (though not nearly as pervasive - nor as jarring - as those employed in Rachel Getting Married) that foster a feeling of gritty realism. The second is the virtually complete lack of melodrama - these are just real people trying to do the best they can, and failing more often than not. None of the characters in this film have any delusions of grandeur - nor are they made to appear as though they do when they obviously do not. The third, of course, is the ghost of Rourke’s own checkered past, which includes, most importantly, a largely unrealized potential as an actor. To the extent that this film works, I don’t think it’s unfair to say that it could not have worked without someone such as Rourke playing the lead.
That being said, however, the film is not without its flaws - the ending being foremost among them. (And this from someone who was a-okay with the abrupt ending of No Country For Old Men.) It’s pretty clear what’s going to happen to Randy, but waiting there in the wings - literally - is Cassidy, who is ultimately a stronger character than Randy because she does what he is unable to do. She walks off the stage in the middle of her set and goes to see Randy in his rematch with the Ayatollah - and in doing so breaks out of the funk that has become her own life. It could be argued that Randy remains true to himself by going back to wresting, even though he knows it will probably kill him; but the self to which he remains true is an incomplete, lesser self - and he chooses to remain that lesser self, despite the fact that his efforts to rise above it are sincere, if not motivated by his own designs.
I’m not arguing that there should have been a happy ending - nor even that there should have been a more complete, which is to say resolved, ending; but I think that Cassidy gets short shrift being left in the background as Randy takes to the ring. Marisa Tomei is up for an Oscar for this role, though she won’t win; and I don’t know that an extra scene at the end, giving a sense of where her character goes next, would have been enough to win a second surprising Oscar for her - but it would have gone a long way toward making The Wrestler a more satisfying film.
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Vicky Cristina Barcelona
I’m not an expert when it comes to Woody Allen movies; I can’t identify the line of demarcation between his classic films and the slightly goofier things he’s been doing lately. I know that I’ve only seen two of the classic movies (although one of them might be the classic Woody Allen Movie), Husbands And Wives and Manhattan; and I’ve seen a little less than half of the output since Small Time Crooks, including the most recent picture, Vicky Cristina Barcelona.
Not being an expert is the reason that I don’t know the answer to the next question, and so have to ask it: When Mia Farrow and Diane Keaton were to Allen, in their turns, what Edie and her ilk were to Warhol, were they always cast as lighter-than-air quasi-bimbos whose every utterance landed somewhere between banal and idiotic? The reason I ask is that Allen’s latest Superstar, Scarlett Johansson, fits that mold perfectly in both Vicky Cristina Barcelona and Scoop; her observations are only slightly more insightful than the bombshells of wisdom Deanna Troi dropped on the crew of the Enterprise.
It’s almost like Woody Allen doesn’t even take himself seriously anymore, perhaps knowing full well that most of his audience stopped doing so years ago. Apart from the slightly bohemian setting, Vicky Cristina Barcelona might as well be Husbands And Wives Redux, except that Allen has already made all of these points before, and did a better job of it in the previous picture. And yet...I sort of liked VIcky Cristina Barcelona, even though I don’t think it’s all that great a movie.
With all of the other movies out there to Netflix, though, is it even worth the time to hunt and peck through the Woody Allen oeuvre for the gems that might be there (among the ones that are not already well known as gems) - or should I just watch Match Point and call it a day?
Not being an expert is the reason that I don’t know the answer to the next question, and so have to ask it: When Mia Farrow and Diane Keaton were to Allen, in their turns, what Edie and her ilk were to Warhol, were they always cast as lighter-than-air quasi-bimbos whose every utterance landed somewhere between banal and idiotic? The reason I ask is that Allen’s latest Superstar, Scarlett Johansson, fits that mold perfectly in both Vicky Cristina Barcelona and Scoop; her observations are only slightly more insightful than the bombshells of wisdom Deanna Troi dropped on the crew of the Enterprise.
It’s almost like Woody Allen doesn’t even take himself seriously anymore, perhaps knowing full well that most of his audience stopped doing so years ago. Apart from the slightly bohemian setting, Vicky Cristina Barcelona might as well be Husbands And Wives Redux, except that Allen has already made all of these points before, and did a better job of it in the previous picture. And yet...I sort of liked VIcky Cristina Barcelona, even though I don’t think it’s all that great a movie.
With all of the other movies out there to Netflix, though, is it even worth the time to hunt and peck through the Woody Allen oeuvre for the gems that might be there (among the ones that are not already well known as gems) - or should I just watch Match Point and call it a day?
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
Movin' Out
So on Sunday we went to a ballet. No kidding. An honest-to-Darwin ballet, although I think it’s actually billed as a musical; either way, it’s not the kind of thing that I would usually do. On the other hand...this was neither your usual musical nor your usual ballet - I don’t think. My experience with musicals, since high school ended, has been fairly limited, and pretty much begins and ends with The Sound Of Music, which is the only musical that I actually enjoy.
But a funny thing happened on the way to the Murat - a few years back now, that wacky Twlya Tharp decided she was going to put together a stage production (the production notes say that the thing was “conceived by” Twyla Tharp - okay) that revolved around some of the better known “characters” in Billy Joel’s songs. I think it takes a pretty good songwriter to craft songs that actually make you think of the subjects of those songs as characters.
Right off the top of my head, I’m having trouble thinking of many other songwriters whose songs make me think of characters - or characters that seem as real as the characters in Billy Joel songs. Some Bob Dylan songs leap to mind - probably most people would agree with “Tangled Up In Blue” and “Hurricane” as the most notable examples, although since the latter is about real people I sort of discount it; and there are some Beatles songs that certainly fit the bill. Actually, there are lots of Beatles songs that fit the bill - “Eleanor Rigby,” “Ob La Di, Ob La Da,” “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” - although I think the best example has to be “Rocky Raccoon.”
Discounting “Hurricane,” the only song in that list that has characters that feel remotely real, in the tangible sense of the word, is “Tangled Up In Blue.” But Anthony working in the grocery store...saving his pennies for someday? Brenda and Eddie, who had had it already by the summer of seventy-five? Virginia, who is told that it’s better to laugh with the sinners than cry with the saints because the sinners are much more fun?
Yeah, those cats feel real to me. Does it have anything to do with the fact that Billy Joel is a New Yorker? Damn straight it does. (Due respect to Bob Dylan, but he ain’t a New Yorker. You gotta be born and raised on those mean streets. Perhaps I am mistaken and someone can correct me...but I don’t operate under the assumption that there are any mean streets in Hibbing, Minnesota.) I was born right here in Indianapolis, Indiana, but there is something about New York that resonates in my soul. My Dad is from Bayonne, New Jersey, which is close to New York, though not of it. Some kind of yen for the Big Apple probably passed through the blood. The fondness for beer certainly did.
But anyway...it’s not just the New York connection. There’s also a college connection. Everybody can think back to college and probably think right away of three or four songs - maybe even three or four albums - that form the beginning of the soundtrack of their college years (and if that’s not a Rob Gordon “all time top five” blog post waiting to happen, I’m sure I don’t know what is). One of those albums for me (while technically a compilation and not a real album) is the first two volumes of Billy Joel’s greatest hits. (Yes, there are two new songs on the album. Don’t even get me started on what a bunch of shit it is to put one or two new songs on a greatest hits package.)
I have a somewhat bizarrely selective memory. I think I recall staying up all night (or most of the night) in college once while Billy Joel songs played in the background from one or the other of those CDs. I remember for sure playing hearts with Heather and Jason and Kristen in Kristen’s basement and at some point hearing the song “Don’t Ask Me Why.” The jazz band in high school played “Just The Way You Are” one year. I still think it’s the most overrated Billy Joel song ever. Storm Front and its quasi-megahit “We Didn’t Start The Fire” closed out the 80s just as I was really beginning to get into pop music. (And that’s pop as in “short for popular,” not the bubblegum crap, although I did like some of that back then. But let’s not dwell on that - nor on the fact that Debbie Gibson was my first concert.)
Billy Joel was also the back end of a double-concert weekend in the spring of my freshman year in college. Both shows were at Market Square Arena, and it’s still the only time I’ve ever gone to back-to-back concerts. The front end of that weekend was Rush, touring to support Counterparts. Best. Show. Ever. Also at that Billy Joel show? Amy, though I didn’t know her yet and had only even met her once to that point. She was in the front row with one of her friends from college. Why? Billy Joel apparently has - or had - a lackey who walks the crowd before the show and gives front row tickets to hotties. Two girls from the dining hall I worked at that year were also at that show and were in the front row.
One last Billy Joel memory...the Grammy awards (I think) for whichever year he would have been invited to play “The River Of Dreams.” There’s a long pause in the song between the second verse and the third chorus, and he held that pause for at least twice as long when he played on the show, and muttered into the microphone, “Valuable advertising time going by...valuable advertising time going by...valuable advertising time going by.”
But I digress. Several paragraphs ago, this was about going to the ballet on Sunday. By now, of course, you’ve puzzled out the fact that the show in question is “Movin’ Out,” which played the Murat this past weekend. It was a sort-of Valentine’s Day present for Amy. We don’t really do presents much anymore, at least not of the material kind. I have more than enough “stuff,” although I can never seem to get rid of any of it. I always tell myself that I’m going to read some of the books on my shelves and then sell or donate them...and yet the stack of library books next to my reading chair is always about a foot high.
Anyway...I had heard that “Movin’ Out” would be in town, but I assumed that tickets would be too expensive, or gone right away - the show was huge on Broadway and is on at least its second tour across the country. But when I checked Livemaster or Nationtickets - or what the hell ever - a couple of weeks ago, I discovered that both of those assumptions were wrong. Tickets were both available, and relatively cheap, at twenty-five bucks. That sealed the deal.
Unfortunately, I don’t have enough - which is to say any - experience with musicals or ballets of the live variety to really be able to review the production, except to say that I quite liked it. It’s a ballet in the technical sense because it’s a story acted out by players who don’t actually recite any lines; on the other hand, all of the musical numbers are actual songs sung by a band that was situated on a stage elevated above and slightly behind the dancers on the actual stage.
The story started out with Brenda and Eddie from “Scenes From An Italian Restaurant,” who got married and then divorced, as they did in the song; from there Brenda hooks up with Tony from “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song),” and there are a couple of characters called James and Judy who are also a couple (I think) and moved in the same crowd with Brenda, Eddie, and Tony. I don’t know the song with James and Judy, though. The fellows all wind up going to Vietnam (the lyrics in “Italian Restaurant” are changed slightly to have Brenda and Eddie get married in the summer of ‘65 rather than the summer of ‘75, because there was obviously no one being sent to Vietnam in 1975), one of them gets whacked, and then, even though “they couldn’t go back to the greasers,” all of the friends who survive manage to reconnect and move on with their lives.
The songs were mostly excellent, even if the guy singing them didn’t quite have the chops that Billy Joel had when he recorded the songs. That lack of chops in places took nothing away from the energy he projected, and was helped along by some very capable background vocalists - and it was clear that the singer, the “Piano Man,” don’tcha know, was channeling Billy Joel and doing a pretty good job for a dude who looked a lot more like John Popper than Billy Joel.
The best number was “We Didn’t Start The Fire,” and what you have to do immediately is forget the post-modern music video that you saw on MTV and even the somewhat goofy march of the lyrics. The number came during the first act, when the guys were in Vietnam, and the action on stage was a night battle, and the song was played as a relentless, heavy, chord-laden barrage that was practically a death march. Try to get your head around the lyrics of that song backed by the heavy guitars from R.E.M.’s Monster - not the poppy chords of “What’s The Frequency, Kenneth?” nor the acidic, sour drone of “Bang And Blame” or “Crush With Eyeliner,” but something more along the lines of “King Of Comedy.” And then throw in a dash of the Metallica album ...And Justice For All. Your head spinning yet? I think that was probably the idea.
The other exceptional musical number started with “Pressure” and stopped mid-song to go right into “Goodnight, Saigon.” It’s probably not a coincidence that those songs are back-to-back on the album they both appeared on (The Nylon Curtain). The latter is a very long song, and they didn’t play the whole thing, but they did do the most haunting lines - the ones that best spoke to the problem with the war in Vietnam:
They heard the hum of the motors
They counted the rotors
And waited for us to arrive
I didn’t follow along with all of the characters as well as I probably should have - that inexperience, again, with the form of the production (and I don’t think it helped that most of the guys looked an awful lot alike and so did the girls, except for the brunette, who I think was Brenda) - but it worked for me, mostly because I love Billy Joel’s songs. Amy was worried that I would not like hearing someone other than Billy Joel singing those songs, and I wondered ahead of time if that would be the case, but it wasn’t. Like I said, the “Piano Man” (credited as three different guys in the notes, although I believe the cast listing for our show said it was a guy called Jon Abrams) clearly had his role as troubadour down pat and did as good a job being Billy Joel as I could imagine being done by anyone who isn’t Billy Joel.
But here’s how I know that it really worked for me. Before we got our seats, we briefly perused the tiny souvenir stand set up in the theatre lobby. One of the items for sale was the cast recording on CD of the Broadway show. I thought before I saw the show that I would certainly not need a CD of, basically, Billy Joel covers, no matter how good they were. I have volumes one and two of his greatest hits, as well as a couple of other albums that I have ripped into iTunes - and I figured I could mix together a CD of the songs from the show if I wanted to re-live it. A day later, though...I’m not so sure. There was an energy to the show - actually, even though I hate this word because of its corporate connotations, there was a synergy to the show that elevated those songs in that combination to something more than they would be on a mix CD. I think that might be a very acceptable definition of art.
But a funny thing happened on the way to the Murat - a few years back now, that wacky Twlya Tharp decided she was going to put together a stage production (the production notes say that the thing was “conceived by” Twyla Tharp - okay) that revolved around some of the better known “characters” in Billy Joel’s songs. I think it takes a pretty good songwriter to craft songs that actually make you think of the subjects of those songs as characters.
Right off the top of my head, I’m having trouble thinking of many other songwriters whose songs make me think of characters - or characters that seem as real as the characters in Billy Joel songs. Some Bob Dylan songs leap to mind - probably most people would agree with “Tangled Up In Blue” and “Hurricane” as the most notable examples, although since the latter is about real people I sort of discount it; and there are some Beatles songs that certainly fit the bill. Actually, there are lots of Beatles songs that fit the bill - “Eleanor Rigby,” “Ob La Di, Ob La Da,” “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” - although I think the best example has to be “Rocky Raccoon.”
Discounting “Hurricane,” the only song in that list that has characters that feel remotely real, in the tangible sense of the word, is “Tangled Up In Blue.” But Anthony working in the grocery store...saving his pennies for someday? Brenda and Eddie, who had had it already by the summer of seventy-five? Virginia, who is told that it’s better to laugh with the sinners than cry with the saints because the sinners are much more fun?
Yeah, those cats feel real to me. Does it have anything to do with the fact that Billy Joel is a New Yorker? Damn straight it does. (Due respect to Bob Dylan, but he ain’t a New Yorker. You gotta be born and raised on those mean streets. Perhaps I am mistaken and someone can correct me...but I don’t operate under the assumption that there are any mean streets in Hibbing, Minnesota.) I was born right here in Indianapolis, Indiana, but there is something about New York that resonates in my soul. My Dad is from Bayonne, New Jersey, which is close to New York, though not of it. Some kind of yen for the Big Apple probably passed through the blood. The fondness for beer certainly did.
But anyway...it’s not just the New York connection. There’s also a college connection. Everybody can think back to college and probably think right away of three or four songs - maybe even three or four albums - that form the beginning of the soundtrack of their college years (and if that’s not a Rob Gordon “all time top five” blog post waiting to happen, I’m sure I don’t know what is). One of those albums for me (while technically a compilation and not a real album) is the first two volumes of Billy Joel’s greatest hits. (Yes, there are two new songs on the album. Don’t even get me started on what a bunch of shit it is to put one or two new songs on a greatest hits package.)
I have a somewhat bizarrely selective memory. I think I recall staying up all night (or most of the night) in college once while Billy Joel songs played in the background from one or the other of those CDs. I remember for sure playing hearts with Heather and Jason and Kristen in Kristen’s basement and at some point hearing the song “Don’t Ask Me Why.” The jazz band in high school played “Just The Way You Are” one year. I still think it’s the most overrated Billy Joel song ever. Storm Front and its quasi-megahit “We Didn’t Start The Fire” closed out the 80s just as I was really beginning to get into pop music. (And that’s pop as in “short for popular,” not the bubblegum crap, although I did like some of that back then. But let’s not dwell on that - nor on the fact that Debbie Gibson was my first concert.)
Billy Joel was also the back end of a double-concert weekend in the spring of my freshman year in college. Both shows were at Market Square Arena, and it’s still the only time I’ve ever gone to back-to-back concerts. The front end of that weekend was Rush, touring to support Counterparts. Best. Show. Ever. Also at that Billy Joel show? Amy, though I didn’t know her yet and had only even met her once to that point. She was in the front row with one of her friends from college. Why? Billy Joel apparently has - or had - a lackey who walks the crowd before the show and gives front row tickets to hotties. Two girls from the dining hall I worked at that year were also at that show and were in the front row.
One last Billy Joel memory...the Grammy awards (I think) for whichever year he would have been invited to play “The River Of Dreams.” There’s a long pause in the song between the second verse and the third chorus, and he held that pause for at least twice as long when he played on the show, and muttered into the microphone, “Valuable advertising time going by...valuable advertising time going by...valuable advertising time going by.”
But I digress. Several paragraphs ago, this was about going to the ballet on Sunday. By now, of course, you’ve puzzled out the fact that the show in question is “Movin’ Out,” which played the Murat this past weekend. It was a sort-of Valentine’s Day present for Amy. We don’t really do presents much anymore, at least not of the material kind. I have more than enough “stuff,” although I can never seem to get rid of any of it. I always tell myself that I’m going to read some of the books on my shelves and then sell or donate them...and yet the stack of library books next to my reading chair is always about a foot high.
Anyway...I had heard that “Movin’ Out” would be in town, but I assumed that tickets would be too expensive, or gone right away - the show was huge on Broadway and is on at least its second tour across the country. But when I checked Livemaster or Nationtickets - or what the hell ever - a couple of weeks ago, I discovered that both of those assumptions were wrong. Tickets were both available, and relatively cheap, at twenty-five bucks. That sealed the deal.
Unfortunately, I don’t have enough - which is to say any - experience with musicals or ballets of the live variety to really be able to review the production, except to say that I quite liked it. It’s a ballet in the technical sense because it’s a story acted out by players who don’t actually recite any lines; on the other hand, all of the musical numbers are actual songs sung by a band that was situated on a stage elevated above and slightly behind the dancers on the actual stage.
The story started out with Brenda and Eddie from “Scenes From An Italian Restaurant,” who got married and then divorced, as they did in the song; from there Brenda hooks up with Tony from “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song),” and there are a couple of characters called James and Judy who are also a couple (I think) and moved in the same crowd with Brenda, Eddie, and Tony. I don’t know the song with James and Judy, though. The fellows all wind up going to Vietnam (the lyrics in “Italian Restaurant” are changed slightly to have Brenda and Eddie get married in the summer of ‘65 rather than the summer of ‘75, because there was obviously no one being sent to Vietnam in 1975), one of them gets whacked, and then, even though “they couldn’t go back to the greasers,” all of the friends who survive manage to reconnect and move on with their lives.
The songs were mostly excellent, even if the guy singing them didn’t quite have the chops that Billy Joel had when he recorded the songs. That lack of chops in places took nothing away from the energy he projected, and was helped along by some very capable background vocalists - and it was clear that the singer, the “Piano Man,” don’tcha know, was channeling Billy Joel and doing a pretty good job for a dude who looked a lot more like John Popper than Billy Joel.
The best number was “We Didn’t Start The Fire,” and what you have to do immediately is forget the post-modern music video that you saw on MTV and even the somewhat goofy march of the lyrics. The number came during the first act, when the guys were in Vietnam, and the action on stage was a night battle, and the song was played as a relentless, heavy, chord-laden barrage that was practically a death march. Try to get your head around the lyrics of that song backed by the heavy guitars from R.E.M.’s Monster - not the poppy chords of “What’s The Frequency, Kenneth?” nor the acidic, sour drone of “Bang And Blame” or “Crush With Eyeliner,” but something more along the lines of “King Of Comedy.” And then throw in a dash of the Metallica album ...And Justice For All. Your head spinning yet? I think that was probably the idea.
The other exceptional musical number started with “Pressure” and stopped mid-song to go right into “Goodnight, Saigon.” It’s probably not a coincidence that those songs are back-to-back on the album they both appeared on (The Nylon Curtain). The latter is a very long song, and they didn’t play the whole thing, but they did do the most haunting lines - the ones that best spoke to the problem with the war in Vietnam:
They heard the hum of the motors
They counted the rotors
And waited for us to arrive
I didn’t follow along with all of the characters as well as I probably should have - that inexperience, again, with the form of the production (and I don’t think it helped that most of the guys looked an awful lot alike and so did the girls, except for the brunette, who I think was Brenda) - but it worked for me, mostly because I love Billy Joel’s songs. Amy was worried that I would not like hearing someone other than Billy Joel singing those songs, and I wondered ahead of time if that would be the case, but it wasn’t. Like I said, the “Piano Man” (credited as three different guys in the notes, although I believe the cast listing for our show said it was a guy called Jon Abrams) clearly had his role as troubadour down pat and did as good a job being Billy Joel as I could imagine being done by anyone who isn’t Billy Joel.
But here’s how I know that it really worked for me. Before we got our seats, we briefly perused the tiny souvenir stand set up in the theatre lobby. One of the items for sale was the cast recording on CD of the Broadway show. I thought before I saw the show that I would certainly not need a CD of, basically, Billy Joel covers, no matter how good they were. I have volumes one and two of his greatest hits, as well as a couple of other albums that I have ripped into iTunes - and I figured I could mix together a CD of the songs from the show if I wanted to re-live it. A day later, though...I’m not so sure. There was an energy to the show - actually, even though I hate this word because of its corporate connotations, there was a synergy to the show that elevated those songs in that combination to something more than they would be on a mix CD. I think that might be a very acceptable definition of art.
Saturday, February 14, 2009
There's My Church, I Sing In The Choir
Charles Darwin was born on the same day as Abraham Lincoln. You may not have heard about that, what with all the talk about Lincoln's birthday and all the talk about how our grumpy new President is learning the hard way that it's a hell of a lot easier to run for President than it is to be President. Feel free to look away if evolution makes you uncomfortable; if it does not make you uncomfortable (and you're in the mood for a link-fest), click here for a post concerning evolution on Cosmic Log, the lovely blog run by MSNBC science editor Alan Boyle. The first point he makes is that quite a lot of religious congregations will be talking about religion and science this weekend, which has apparently come to be known as Evolution Weekend, a project devoted to dispelling the myth that religion and evolution can't get along. The really cool part? The guy who started the whole thing, Michael Zimmerman, is the dean of the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences at our very own Butler University. Yeah...progressive religious thinking in Indiana. Who knew? (And yes...sigh...that is sarcasm.)
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
Roger Ebert And The Reader
I was having lunch at work yesterday when I stumbled upon this blog post by Roger Ebert, which intentionally takes the most circuitous route possible to - perhaps - explain how it is that Mr. Ebert came to interpret The Reader in the way that he did. I thought his review of the film was excellent because it got the point that Hanna's secret - not the Holocaust, not the love affair, not the trial and her subsequent imprisonment - is the central subject of the story, and that all of the resulting details and events follow from it. Some might say that this minimizes the atrocities committed by Hanna, but I disagree; the gravity of those atrocities - with the understanding that they are atrocities that would not have been committed absent the secret that troubles Hanna's soul - illustrates the power of that secret and its effect on the whole of Hanna's life.
I sort of wish that I had had Mr. Ebert's blog post to read while considering my own review of The Reader, because most of the above paragraph would have served well a review of that film, with respect to the construction of the story, and I only touched on it obliquely when I wrote my review. Alas, though, Mr. Ebert's blog post was from this past Sunday, so could not have been read before I wrote about the movie. For some reason, I neither mentioned nor linked to Mr. Ebert's review of The Reader when I wrote my own review of the film. The link can be found here, and the review is excellent. At some point along the line, Roger Ebert ceased to be just a reviewer of films and instead became a combination film reviewer and film historian - and is, above all, a fine writer.
I sort of wish that I had had Mr. Ebert's blog post to read while considering my own review of The Reader, because most of the above paragraph would have served well a review of that film, with respect to the construction of the story, and I only touched on it obliquely when I wrote my review. Alas, though, Mr. Ebert's blog post was from this past Sunday, so could not have been read before I wrote about the movie. For some reason, I neither mentioned nor linked to Mr. Ebert's review of The Reader when I wrote my own review of the film. The link can be found here, and the review is excellent. At some point along the line, Roger Ebert ceased to be just a reviewer of films and instead became a combination film reviewer and film historian - and is, above all, a fine writer.
Saturday, February 07, 2009
Praise Song For The Day
A sampling of links concerning the poem written by Elizabeth Alexander for President Obama's inauguration, including the text of the poem posted on poets.org with permission of Graywolf Press, which is publishing a chapbook edition of the poem; a review of the poem from the Christian Science Monitor; and the author's website.
Monday, February 02, 2009
Things I Don't Understand
Why a package of socks would have a re-closable Ziploc-style device at the top of the bag.
Saturday, January 31, 2009
Friday, January 23, 2009
2008 Academy Award Nominations
There’s always next year, right? That pretty much sums up my feeling about this year’s Oscar nominees - and my feeling about the Chicago Cubs. Though much of what was handed down is exactly (or awfully close to) what I expected, there were some surprises. To wit:
• Clearly, a number of people both saw and remembered Frozen River, which is excellent. They’re probably already engraving Meryl Streep’s name on the Best Actress trophy, but that Melissa Leo is nominated in the same category really ought to give them pause. Bet on Streep, but don’t be surprised if the Oscar goes to Leo.
• Jenny Lumet may be pondering a slightly less expensive dress for the ceremony, providing that she’s still planning to go - and Courtney Hunt may be calling her about that dress.
• No noms for Gran Torino, either because even the venerable Clint only gets the love for one picture a year - this year, and for reasons passing understanding, the picture is Changeling - or because no one was much interested in seeing Dirty Harry and the Sunnyvale Retirement Village.
• Richard Jenkins - I’m rooting for him to win Best Actor on general principle, even if I wind up liking Mickey Rourke better when I finally get around to seeing The Wrestler.
• Almost no love for Revolutionary Road, a superior film to The Reader, which did get a surprising amount of love. Revolutionary Road is up for Art Direction, Costumes, and Supporting Actor and has a 0% of winning any of them. If it has even a tiny chance, it’s for Art Direction, but this is one of the few categories where The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button actually deserves to win.
And speaking of The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button, you know what would have been nice? A Supporting Actress nomination for Tilda Swinton, even if the bit near the end that reprised her character was goofy. I don't think it would change anything - Penelope Cruz is going to win that category - but she was excellent in the tiny bit of the film she was in.
• Clearly, a number of people both saw and remembered Frozen River, which is excellent. They’re probably already engraving Meryl Streep’s name on the Best Actress trophy, but that Melissa Leo is nominated in the same category really ought to give them pause. Bet on Streep, but don’t be surprised if the Oscar goes to Leo.
• Jenny Lumet may be pondering a slightly less expensive dress for the ceremony, providing that she’s still planning to go - and Courtney Hunt may be calling her about that dress.
• No noms for Gran Torino, either because even the venerable Clint only gets the love for one picture a year - this year, and for reasons passing understanding, the picture is Changeling - or because no one was much interested in seeing Dirty Harry and the Sunnyvale Retirement Village.
• Richard Jenkins - I’m rooting for him to win Best Actor on general principle, even if I wind up liking Mickey Rourke better when I finally get around to seeing The Wrestler.
• Almost no love for Revolutionary Road, a superior film to The Reader, which did get a surprising amount of love. Revolutionary Road is up for Art Direction, Costumes, and Supporting Actor and has a 0% of winning any of them. If it has even a tiny chance, it’s for Art Direction, but this is one of the few categories where The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button actually deserves to win.
And speaking of The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button, you know what would have been nice? A Supporting Actress nomination for Tilda Swinton, even if the bit near the end that reprised her character was goofy. I don't think it would change anything - Penelope Cruz is going to win that category - but she was excellent in the tiny bit of the film she was in.
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
1.20.09 (Or, Rising Unemployment Is Not Always A Bad Thing)

There was a headline on the news tonight that asked if the expectations were perhaps too high for President Obama. Well, of course the expectations are too high. Unless he takes the oath of office, strolls down to the mall, and walks across the reflecting pool while snapping his fingers and chucking fishes and loaves at the adoring onlookers...if that happens, then it’s possible he’ll be able to live up to the expectations that have been building for his presidency since November 4th.
He’s not going to fix everything. He may not even fix most things. Hell...he may not even actually fix one single thing. But there will be improvement. If he can manage to keep from obstructing the work of Congress, there will be improvement; if he reverses President Bush’s policies on science, particularly on embryonic stem cells, there will be improvement; if he can help Israel and Hamas maintain the cease-fire, which is currently about as stable as Ron Kovic on a tightrope, there will be improvement. And so on.
Hell...if he can convince the morons running the BCS to peel one game off the regular season schedule, reduce the number of bowl games by a third, and introduce an eight team, three week playoff (with seedings based loosely on the current BCS ranking methodology, corrected to ensure that every team with a zero in the loss column at the end of the regular season gets into the playoff - and, on general principle, fuck Notre Dame), there will be improvement.
Will he make mistakes? Sure he will. Will people deride him as worthless from the moment of his first mistake? Sure they will. But these are people who thought it was a good idea to vote for Sarah Palin, so there’s clearly no reason to start taking them seriously anytime soon.
President Obama, do not be cowed by the kind of Republicans who torpedoed the presidency of Bill Clinton. These cheap, simple people think humans and dinosaurs roamed the earth at the same time. To acknowledge them is to encourage the feeble-minded never to improve their minds and get those neural synapses firing. Stand up and do the good work you talked about during the Neverending Campaign. We know you won’t keep every single campaign promise, but then again, no reasoned person expects you to. Some of us understand that running for President is practically nothing like actually being President. You have to say a lot of things on the campaign trail to pander to voters, most of whom are dolts. (Humans riding dinosaurs? Seriously?)
And even if you don’t get much done in four years, don’t worry. A precedent has been set. You can screw up completely, lie to the American people, send our troops to the desert to die for no good reason and with no exit strategy (coherent or otherwise) in place - and still manage to be re-elected. Just think how well you’ll do in 2012 if you actually do a few things right. (Hint: Filibuster-proof Senate, which will eliminate even the most obnoxious and onerous behavior of the obstructionist Republicans).
Best wishes and good luck, Mr. President. We’re counting on you - not to raise Lazarus from the dead, or turn water into wine...but rather to do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


