That was a good comment (and I did not delete the post because of you), although your Shakespeare analogy is shaky. People can love Shakespeare, but it is not, generally speaking, a system by which people live; also, people are rarely killed or disowned because of Shakespeare plays (regardless of how well they are staged or filmed). With respect to the idea of the beauty of the art being lost in translation, though, your analogy is sound.
And, where religion as applied by one person causes pain or suffering to another, it ceases to be viable and becomes instead tyranny (or, when wrapped in a turban, terrorism). The course of two people's lives has been shattered because of one woman's application of religion. The state of Indiana offers Patrick's partner no recourse under the law - and this is, at the very least, a tacit endorsement of religion by the state. No system that tramples the rights of those who do not accept its primacy can stand in a society of the truly free.
Religion, when you get right down to the bare bones, is personal. As such, its correct application cannot be taught, per se. No one can be moved to action by the order of someone acting on beliefs that they believe are more right than the beliefs of that other person. In the secular world, that is tyranny. Fold religion into the mix and it becomes theocracy.
Religion can be very comforting for those who feel that they need it. On the other side of the coin, however, religion can be extremely dangerous - especially for those who have come to the airtight conclusion that they do not need it in the least.
People hold up freedom as an ideal in this country - maybe more than in any country in the world. What far too many of them fail to realize is that the idea of freedom includes the freedom to reject religion utterly. When the über-religious stop proselytizing to those whom they have not assimilated into the collective, then we can call our society truly free. When that happens, the religious will have stopped believing that the non-religious are wrong; and that will exterminate the possibility of theocracy. Until then, religion can be very, very dangerous.
George W. Bush has vetoed two stem cell bills based on his own personal religious belief. I have a big problem with that. He stood in the way of free scientific inquiry, prevented the going forward of a science that has a potential it will likely never realize (in large part because of his beliefs and the influence of those beliefs on his actions), because of the way he interprets religion. He is afraid, as are many religious people, that the goal of science is to trump religion. This is not the case.
Science seeks merely to explain, but it has the power to explain away nearly everything that religion has offered up as an explanation. The ultra-conservative religious people are afraid of science because they think it will subvert religion. If they believe their own arguments, however, then everything that exists came from their god, and that includes science. But they don't understand this because they are afraid. They are afraid that they are wrong. They are afraid that science will one day answer the biggest question of all.
Why are we here?
I don't believe that science will answer that question. Based on the size of the universe, its age, and the fragile nature of human beings, no human being is likely ever to get to the bottom of why we are here. If God did create man in His own image, then He tied up that loose end pretty nicely. And He gave people the free will to figure out the rest of it.
As for me, I could care less why we're here. I'm here...and that's good enough for me. I'm trying to make the most of it. I don't know why we're here, and I'm not interested in expending the energy to find out. I don't need a complex system of beliefs. I'll take a song...
Why are we here?
Because we're here.
Roll the bones...
Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts
Sunday, August 19, 2007
Sunday, January 21, 2007
One Billion Dollars
I never thought that going to work would make me this rich. Was I ever wrong. Wrong as wrong could be, boy howdy. There I was, just minding my own business, milling about the lobby, when I happened to notice a piece of paper lying on one of the racks that hold our FLM magazines. I ambled over. Glory be - and I say this in almost all honesty - there it was, a billion dollar bill. Some yo-yo had left a billion dollars just lying around for me to find.
Oh Hosanna, oh don't you cry for me. It was almost the same size as real money, and bore colors similar to those found on the new twenty dollar note. But, oh was this one worth so much more than twenty little dollars. See...on the back was the "billion dollar question," which was: Will you go to heaven? Well...um, no. Have you ever lied? Shit. Stolen anything? Shit. Used God's name in vain? Goddamnit. Unless one or more of those, including the last one, was a foul tip, I'm out of there.
Good thing there are web sites for future brimstone fodder such as me. One of them, pimping a radio and, apparently, TV program called The Way Of The Master (which actually sounds kind of cool, until you remember that Bruce Lee is dead), is just sort of run-of-the-mill evangelical propaganda, including many examples of "actual" telephone conversations in which people who had been having doubts about their faith were firmly informed that anything less than full frontal faith in Jay-zus would mean death by wood-chipper and a lifeimte of burning in hell. (That's where they get those videos of fireplaces that you can play on your TV so it makes it look like you have a fireplace. Those are sinners burning in hell - Heathens Gone Wild!)
Anyway, a second web site pimped on the billion dollar bill was for Living Waters, an online portal full of evangelism resources (although, oddly, it makes no mention of where they stockpile all the hot air) - and this one actually had something that made me laugh out loud. Really hard. I was half afraid I was going to wake Amy up. Are you ready for this? Are you sitting down?
There's a board game you can get. Swear to...well, you know. I mean it. There's a board game you can get - apparently people around the world have been clamoring - clamoring, I tell you - for this kind of game, and now, AT LAST, it's available. It's called...Intelligent Design Vs. Evolution, and here's the tag line, which I promise, Dave Barry style, that I am not making up: "At last, a board game that reveals the insanity of perhaps the greatest hoax of our times - the unscientific 'theory of evolution.'"
Well. So much for that, I guess. I suppose it is safe to say that the people behind this board game will not be working with the people I wrote about yesterday, the ones who are going to work on global warming with the scientists. There are literally tens of millions of people in this country who buy into this kind of nonsense - depending on where you glean your information, the number is between forty and one hundred million people.
But hey, before this gets too dark and scary, let's go back to the first web site I mentioned, The Way Of The Master, and end on a light note. One of the little menus on their web page leads you to a News page (which you can get to by clicking on the above link), where they tell you what they're up to, what's new and exciting in their corner of the Internet. The News page contains not one, but two, jokes about people with only one tooth, and it also talks about the upcoming new design of their web site. They say that it's going to be a "spanky" new design. Not "brand spanking new," which was probably what they meant. No, a "spanky" new design. Again, I have to reiterate that I am not making any of this up. I swear to...well, you know.
Oh Hosanna, oh don't you cry for me. It was almost the same size as real money, and bore colors similar to those found on the new twenty dollar note. But, oh was this one worth so much more than twenty little dollars. See...on the back was the "billion dollar question," which was: Will you go to heaven? Well...um, no. Have you ever lied? Shit. Stolen anything? Shit. Used God's name in vain? Goddamnit. Unless one or more of those, including the last one, was a foul tip, I'm out of there.
Good thing there are web sites for future brimstone fodder such as me. One of them, pimping a radio and, apparently, TV program called The Way Of The Master (which actually sounds kind of cool, until you remember that Bruce Lee is dead), is just sort of run-of-the-mill evangelical propaganda, including many examples of "actual" telephone conversations in which people who had been having doubts about their faith were firmly informed that anything less than full frontal faith in Jay-zus would mean death by wood-chipper and a lifeimte of burning in hell. (That's where they get those videos of fireplaces that you can play on your TV so it makes it look like you have a fireplace. Those are sinners burning in hell - Heathens Gone Wild!)
Anyway, a second web site pimped on the billion dollar bill was for Living Waters, an online portal full of evangelism resources (although, oddly, it makes no mention of where they stockpile all the hot air) - and this one actually had something that made me laugh out loud. Really hard. I was half afraid I was going to wake Amy up. Are you ready for this? Are you sitting down?
There's a board game you can get. Swear to...well, you know. I mean it. There's a board game you can get - apparently people around the world have been clamoring - clamoring, I tell you - for this kind of game, and now, AT LAST, it's available. It's called...Intelligent Design Vs. Evolution, and here's the tag line, which I promise, Dave Barry style, that I am not making up: "At last, a board game that reveals the insanity of perhaps the greatest hoax of our times - the unscientific 'theory of evolution.'"
Well. So much for that, I guess. I suppose it is safe to say that the people behind this board game will not be working with the people I wrote about yesterday, the ones who are going to work on global warming with the scientists. There are literally tens of millions of people in this country who buy into this kind of nonsense - depending on where you glean your information, the number is between forty and one hundred million people.
But hey, before this gets too dark and scary, let's go back to the first web site I mentioned, The Way Of The Master, and end on a light note. One of the little menus on their web page leads you to a News page (which you can get to by clicking on the above link), where they tell you what they're up to, what's new and exciting in their corner of the Internet. The News page contains not one, but two, jokes about people with only one tooth, and it also talks about the upcoming new design of their web site. They say that it's going to be a "spanky" new design. Not "brand spanking new," which was probably what they meant. No, a "spanky" new design. Again, I have to reiterate that I am not making any of this up. I swear to...well, you know.
Tuesday, December 12, 2006
We Would Like To Pre-Board Those Passengers Who Have Checked Their Reason With Their Luggage
Here’s that thing on the Christmas trees at the Seattle-Tacoma International airport. Apparently a rabbi with the Chabad Lubavitch organization has threatened to sue the airport if they do not put up an 8-foot tall menorah in order to “balance the message” of the Christmas trees - this according to an article posted on MSNBC, culled from KXAN-TV in Austin, Texas. NewsCloud has an article credited to a Seattle Post-Intelligencer reporter that goes into a bit more detail. And now it appears, courtesty of the Post-Intelligencer itself, that the trees are going back up - and might already be back up.
According to the Post-Intelligencer story, Chabad Lubavitch started discussions with the airport about putting up a menorah back in October, then hauled out the threat of a lawsuit about a week ago.
That’s a bit of a problem - have the authorities at the Port of Seattle been stonewalling all this time, trying to keep Chabad Lubavitch off their backs, maybe until Christmas had passed and everyone had forgotten about it? And if Chabad Lubavitch was really going to sue over it, why wait until now?
The airport’s argument would come back to the ubiquity of Christmas trees and other Christmas decorations all over the country at this time of year, and while it is true that Christmas decorations have become obnoxiously ubiquitous, the argument does not hold for displaying one set of decorations exclusively. The commissioners of the Port of Seattle are elected officials who serve four-year terms and set policy at the airport.
Technically, then, putting up Christmas trees - and especially denying requests by other religious groups to put up decorations representing faiths other than Christianity - constitutes an endorsement of religion, which is, again technically, a violation of the First Amendment.
Their argument for taking down the trees in the first place was that, if they left the trees up and also erected the menorah, they would then have to take the time to find out what other religious decorations they would have to put up in order not to be stepping on anyone else’s toes this holiday season - never mind the even more technical fact that such a comprehensive display of religious decorations might, in its totality, constitute an endorsement of religion, generally, which would also violate the First Amendment.
So...at bottom what we have is a culture clash - between what Christians think of as the true meaning of Christmas, and what secular America thinks of as the festive, commercial, end-of-the-year meaning of Christmas. Christmas has become so secular in America that most of us spend most of the time thinking of Christmas as a time of year, not a celebration of someone’s birth.
The problem is that no amount of commercial spin can completely extricate the secular notion of Christmas from the religious notion of Christmas; Christmas is Christmas because the Christians made it that way. We cannot assume that people of religions other than Christianity are just going to sit back and accept the continued emphasis on Christmas at the expense of celebrating the holidays of those other religions - nor should we.
The Port of Seattle was correct to remove the Christmas trees in the face of objections against them - and though this rabbi person claims not to have been protesting the trees specifically, he seems to be somewhat full of shit, to me. The trees were the scapegoat in this case - the unwitting victims of this man’s, and his organization’s, objection to the preeminence of Christmas at this time of year, and the lack of attention paid to other religions at the same time of year. He was protesting the fact of the trees being there because they were the ONLY decorations in place - and he believes that if a Christmas tree should have pride of place in an airport, then so should an 8-foot high menorah.
That the trees are going back up, of course, has nothing to do with any kind of religion - apart from the religion of wanting to keep your job come next election day. I suspect that it will be difficult for most Americans to look at this kind of thing as anything but an attack on Christmas. Then again, most Americans are fucking idiots. It’s not an attack on anything. It’s a Jewish fellow and his organization asking for equal representation. Did they need to threaten a lawsuit? Maybe they did, if they were ignored when they asked nicely. Maybe not - maybe they were just being belligerent. Or maybe it’s just more evidence of how fucking ridiculous religion is.
According to the Post-Intelligencer story, Chabad Lubavitch started discussions with the airport about putting up a menorah back in October, then hauled out the threat of a lawsuit about a week ago.
That’s a bit of a problem - have the authorities at the Port of Seattle been stonewalling all this time, trying to keep Chabad Lubavitch off their backs, maybe until Christmas had passed and everyone had forgotten about it? And if Chabad Lubavitch was really going to sue over it, why wait until now?
The airport’s argument would come back to the ubiquity of Christmas trees and other Christmas decorations all over the country at this time of year, and while it is true that Christmas decorations have become obnoxiously ubiquitous, the argument does not hold for displaying one set of decorations exclusively. The commissioners of the Port of Seattle are elected officials who serve four-year terms and set policy at the airport.
Technically, then, putting up Christmas trees - and especially denying requests by other religious groups to put up decorations representing faiths other than Christianity - constitutes an endorsement of religion, which is, again technically, a violation of the First Amendment.
Their argument for taking down the trees in the first place was that, if they left the trees up and also erected the menorah, they would then have to take the time to find out what other religious decorations they would have to put up in order not to be stepping on anyone else’s toes this holiday season - never mind the even more technical fact that such a comprehensive display of religious decorations might, in its totality, constitute an endorsement of religion, generally, which would also violate the First Amendment.
So...at bottom what we have is a culture clash - between what Christians think of as the true meaning of Christmas, and what secular America thinks of as the festive, commercial, end-of-the-year meaning of Christmas. Christmas has become so secular in America that most of us spend most of the time thinking of Christmas as a time of year, not a celebration of someone’s birth.
The problem is that no amount of commercial spin can completely extricate the secular notion of Christmas from the religious notion of Christmas; Christmas is Christmas because the Christians made it that way. We cannot assume that people of religions other than Christianity are just going to sit back and accept the continued emphasis on Christmas at the expense of celebrating the holidays of those other religions - nor should we.
The Port of Seattle was correct to remove the Christmas trees in the face of objections against them - and though this rabbi person claims not to have been protesting the trees specifically, he seems to be somewhat full of shit, to me. The trees were the scapegoat in this case - the unwitting victims of this man’s, and his organization’s, objection to the preeminence of Christmas at this time of year, and the lack of attention paid to other religions at the same time of year. He was protesting the fact of the trees being there because they were the ONLY decorations in place - and he believes that if a Christmas tree should have pride of place in an airport, then so should an 8-foot high menorah.
That the trees are going back up, of course, has nothing to do with any kind of religion - apart from the religion of wanting to keep your job come next election day. I suspect that it will be difficult for most Americans to look at this kind of thing as anything but an attack on Christmas. Then again, most Americans are fucking idiots. It’s not an attack on anything. It’s a Jewish fellow and his organization asking for equal representation. Did they need to threaten a lawsuit? Maybe they did, if they were ignored when they asked nicely. Maybe not - maybe they were just being belligerent. Or maybe it’s just more evidence of how fucking ridiculous religion is.
Friday, November 03, 2006
What's The Difference Between A Terrorist And An Evangelical? One Carries A Kalashnikov.
I was going to take a pass on this one - it’s just too easy, right? - but that was when it was just innuendo and allegation and possibly even a political ploy in the run-up to Tuesday’s elections. (In point of fact, regardless of what the pastor did or did not do, it IS a political ploy - just because the Evangelicals are the ones in the hot seat doesn’t make it any less political. That being said, however, the movie Jesus Camp is in theatres now, and Ted Haggard’s smiling mug was in the trailer at one point and is probably in the film, too - and perhaps awareness of the movie made the accuser step forward at this time. Regardless, the timing is sketchy at best, and just plain exploitative at worst.)
The issue, of course, is the flap over Pastor Ted Haggard, former President of the National Assocation of Evangelicals, who has been accused by a former male prostitute (the temptation to drop into an Eddie Griffin falsetto and refer to the chap as a “man-ho” is almost too great to pass up) of paying for sex and of buying meth from him.
CNN reported earlier today on its web site that Haggard denied the allegations, but that the acting senior church official, who stepped into Haggard’s vacated leadership position at New Life Church in Colorado Springs, Colorado, stated that there had been “some admission of indiscretion.”
Okay, fine. He said, she said. Or, I suppose in this case: he said, he said. Is it shady, up to this point? Sure it is. He resigned. Had there been no merit whatsoever to any of the accuser’s claims, surely Haggard would have remained at his post and denied, as loudly as possible - have you noticed that Evangelicals tend to do everything as loudly as they possibly can? - everything that this lunatic former prostitute was saying about him. But instead, he, you know, resigned.
Now...CNN is reporting here that Haggard paid the former male prostitute “for a massage,” and bought meth from him but threw it away instead of using it.
So now I revoke my pass-taking, because this has gone past the point of being an election-cycle blip on the radar and gone straight (so to speak) toward the ridiculous. Let’s take a quick second to break down exactly what Haggard has admitted.
He paid a former male prostitute “for a massage.” Doesn’t say how much he paid, nor what the massage entailed, but neither matter. The black and white of it is this: he gave money to another person (it only matters here that it was a man because Haggard is an Evangelical and Evangelicals hate gays) to have that person put his hands on Haggard’s body. And that, friends and neighbors, is a spectacularly effective parsing of English. No one can prove that what he said was a lie, except for the former male prostitute; and that brings it back to he said, he said.
In a world where all the jokes are told when they need to be told, by the people who should be telling them, then Bill Clinton would be the first one in the room to hold up his microphone and ask Ted Haggard to define, specifically, just what he means by the word “massage.” That, of course, will not happen; but I would laugh loud and long if it did.
Then comes the meth he threw away, and I think we’ll just go right back to Bill Clinton on this one - the same guy who admitted to smoking pot but not inhaling. See how the parsing works? He admits the part he can’t hide, and then makes up something vague about the part that no one can prove. Haggard does the same thing by admitting that he bought the meth, but It occurs to me, however, to question why he would admit to buying it at all; and that begs the further question: what is the incontrovertible proof of this purchase that must exist in the world if Haggard felt compelled to admit that he made the purchase?
The same article reports that the former male prostitute took a polygraph test that, upon analysis, “did show deception.” The article also indicates that the former male prostitute, Mike Jones, was exhausted at the time he took the test. Doesn’t sound like he lied, but he also might not quite be telling the truth - or the whole truth. Regardless, why does Jones’ revelation have Haggard doing the duck-and-cover bit? This is the former leader of the country’s largest assimilation of Evangelicals - and he is now caught up in accusations of hypocrisy, lying (er, bearing false witness, I suppose), and criminal activity (for buying the meth).
Sam Harris, a prayer-hater who wrote a religion-bashing book called The End Of Faith and a follow-up to that book called Letter To A Christian Nation, which is essentially the salient points of the first book distilled down into a few dozen pages that are actually readabale and almost enjoyable, should be having a field day with this mess. What a goofy world we live in.
The issue, of course, is the flap over Pastor Ted Haggard, former President of the National Assocation of Evangelicals, who has been accused by a former male prostitute (the temptation to drop into an Eddie Griffin falsetto and refer to the chap as a “man-ho” is almost too great to pass up) of paying for sex and of buying meth from him.
CNN reported earlier today on its web site that Haggard denied the allegations, but that the acting senior church official, who stepped into Haggard’s vacated leadership position at New Life Church in Colorado Springs, Colorado, stated that there had been “some admission of indiscretion.”
Okay, fine. He said, she said. Or, I suppose in this case: he said, he said. Is it shady, up to this point? Sure it is. He resigned. Had there been no merit whatsoever to any of the accuser’s claims, surely Haggard would have remained at his post and denied, as loudly as possible - have you noticed that Evangelicals tend to do everything as loudly as they possibly can? - everything that this lunatic former prostitute was saying about him. But instead, he, you know, resigned.
Now...CNN is reporting here that Haggard paid the former male prostitute “for a massage,” and bought meth from him but threw it away instead of using it.
So now I revoke my pass-taking, because this has gone past the point of being an election-cycle blip on the radar and gone straight (so to speak) toward the ridiculous. Let’s take a quick second to break down exactly what Haggard has admitted.
He paid a former male prostitute “for a massage.” Doesn’t say how much he paid, nor what the massage entailed, but neither matter. The black and white of it is this: he gave money to another person (it only matters here that it was a man because Haggard is an Evangelical and Evangelicals hate gays) to have that person put his hands on Haggard’s body. And that, friends and neighbors, is a spectacularly effective parsing of English. No one can prove that what he said was a lie, except for the former male prostitute; and that brings it back to he said, he said.
In a world where all the jokes are told when they need to be told, by the people who should be telling them, then Bill Clinton would be the first one in the room to hold up his microphone and ask Ted Haggard to define, specifically, just what he means by the word “massage.” That, of course, will not happen; but I would laugh loud and long if it did.
Then comes the meth he threw away, and I think we’ll just go right back to Bill Clinton on this one - the same guy who admitted to smoking pot but not inhaling. See how the parsing works? He admits the part he can’t hide, and then makes up something vague about the part that no one can prove. Haggard does the same thing by admitting that he bought the meth, but It occurs to me, however, to question why he would admit to buying it at all; and that begs the further question: what is the incontrovertible proof of this purchase that must exist in the world if Haggard felt compelled to admit that he made the purchase?
The same article reports that the former male prostitute took a polygraph test that, upon analysis, “did show deception.” The article also indicates that the former male prostitute, Mike Jones, was exhausted at the time he took the test. Doesn’t sound like he lied, but he also might not quite be telling the truth - or the whole truth. Regardless, why does Jones’ revelation have Haggard doing the duck-and-cover bit? This is the former leader of the country’s largest assimilation of Evangelicals - and he is now caught up in accusations of hypocrisy, lying (er, bearing false witness, I suppose), and criminal activity (for buying the meth).
Sam Harris, a prayer-hater who wrote a religion-bashing book called The End Of Faith and a follow-up to that book called Letter To A Christian Nation, which is essentially the salient points of the first book distilled down into a few dozen pages that are actually readabale and almost enjoyable, should be having a field day with this mess. What a goofy world we live in.
Sunday, October 29, 2006
Counting The Cars On The New Jersey Turnpike
This past Wednesday (October 25, 2006), the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled in favor of gay marriage, voting 4-3 to require the state legislature to change state marriage laws to include gay couples, or provide some other way, such as civil unions, for gay couples to be included in the social and finiancial benefits afforded heterosexual married couples. And the three judges who dissented, far from saying that the ruling that passed was wrong, actually would have preferred that the action - that of granting homosexual couples the same rights as heterosexual couples - be taken directly by the court, rather than delegated to the legislature.
Clearly the three dissenting judges were more liberal on the subject, but this might be a case where the more liberal position was not necessarily the best one. Did I really just say that? Yes, I did. And here’s why. One of the conservative positions on this issue has been their opposition to so-called activist judges who they fear will issue rulings that tend to favor gay marriage while ignoring the so-called will of the people. If the court had taken the action themselves, they would have opened themselves up to this kind of criticism from the right; by giving the responsibility back to the legislature, the court has given the people the opportunity to shape the law in a way that satisfies both the court and the people - should the people take this unique opportunity to see the light before it is forced upon their will by the court. The court has made a decision, but left the specifics of that decision up to the will of the people. Sounds like a good idea, but can the will of the people be trusted?
The will of people who have not spent their lives studying law and hearing cases and writing legal opinions, people who have no concept of what the separation of church and state really means, people who subscribe to the laws of the bible they claim to hold in such reverance only to the extent that those laws aren’t, you know, inconvenient to them in any way. The will of people, who, for example, once preferred that schools be segregated. The will of people who voted for George W. Bush the second time.
But let’s step aside from that argument for just a moment, even though it is sort of enjoyable. What, exactly, is the will of all these people? The will of these people is that gays not be allowed to marry.
Okay. Why not?
It’s just wrong.
Okay. Why?
Well...it’s just not natural.
Okay. Would you mind introducing me to all these inorganic gay people you know? I’d love to meet them. Are they like Data from Star Trek?
Well, I mean...it’s just wrong, isn’t it?
Sure it is. In the Bible. Homosexuality is wrong in the Bible, but it’s a protected class in the United States when it comes to just about everything except marriage and presiding over certain congregations (unless you’re really good at keeping secrets and can manage to train yourself only to blow the little altar boys you’re damn sure will keep their mouths shut about it). There are a lot of trespasses in the Bible, and a lot of things you are supposed to do if ye commit one of them unto your lord.
Of course, that’s all Old Testament nonsense. All of those Old Testament penalties were commuted down to one simple prayer in the New Testament; and even that is still nonsense, but now it’s nonsense that is a bit more expedient. It is far easier to utter a few Our Fathers than it is, say, to bring unto your lord a ram without blemish from the flock.
A quick glimpse at a few more of these “trespasses” reveals (skim the eleventh book of Leviticus if you doubt me here) that thou shalt not eat rabbit, pig, shrimp, scallop, oyster, clam, crab, lobster, squid, or octopus, owing to such arbitrary things as cud and scales and whatnot. And you can’t touch them if they’re dead, either, which isn’t a big thing - who really goes around groping dead seafood, apart from, say, fishers of men? - except for the fact that we loves us some football here in America (where we have, conveniently, perverted the term for a sport that the rest of the world loves and about which we know nothing, and have therefore dubbed soccer - and isn’t it odd that we use the term football to describe a game in which exactly two of the fifty-three players on each team ever get to touch the ball with their feet?) and gather round the telly every Sunday afternoon (probably this is a “trespass,” too, the day being Sunday and all) to watch a bunch of fellows compete to see which of their teams can score the most points by passing into the opposing team’s end zone (and doesn’t this act sound vaguely like sodomy, another of those “abominations?”) a ball made from the skin of a dead pig. Oh, and don’t forget that those fellows who are touching the carcass of that unclean, dead animal are doing so on the Sabbath, while on the clock. Better warm up the tar and feathers - or start gathering the stones for the stoning.
So...we have situational ethics and relativism with respect to the reading of Leviticus. It’s not okay for Moses to work on the Sabbath, but it is okay for Peyton Manning to do it. It’s not okay for Aaron to eat the unclean animal, but you go ahead and get that double pepperoni pizza with bacon. Fine. If you are religious, go ahead and apply the rule of your lord in any way you see fit; after all, you made up your day of judgment in the first place, so only you should be worried about having to answer for your hypocrisy when that day arrives. St. Peter’s interview of Pat Robertson alone is going to take a good two to three weeks.
But here’s where we trip another continental drift divide - you can’t apply that kind of biblical law to actions of the state, here meant to include government in any form at any level, from the Federal all the way down to local government at, say, the county level. Not without violating the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Marriage licenses are issued by the clerk of the county court. If a marriage license is refused to a gay couple, the refusal is based either on a law on the books (say, a state law prohibiting such at thing) or the biblical law that prohibits a man from lying with a man as he lies with a woman (Lev. 18:22) and vice versa, although, very technically, it’s not in there, which probably explains why people are more comfortable with lesbians than they are with gay men. Neither can hold without violating the First Amendment - the state law (or any statute at any level of government) goes back to the biblical law, and to uphold the biblical law in a governmental statute is tacit endorsement of the religion that expounds the law.
The problem, of course, even if you can get past the religious hypocrisy, is the idea of the nuclear family, which is the societal result of the embrace of marriage. People will say that the nuclear family is the cornerstone of society. Romantically, that is true; technically, it is not. Human beings are equipped with reason and speech, which separate them from the lower animals, and invest them with the ability to procreate in more ways than just having a fertile male mount a fertile woman and engage in intercourse at a particular time of the month until such time as the male has ejaculated millions of his little paddlers into the woman’s eager birth canal, into which it is hoped that a fertile egg shall descend in enough time to catch one of the intrepid little paddlers before he expires from the effort.
Such is the difference between humans - who conceived of sperm banks - and chimpanzees, who get it on outdoors and yet share better than 99% of their DNA with humans. It’s not illegal for unmarried women to have babies by artificial insemination; it’s not even illegal for gay couples to bear children this way; and it’s not illegal for gay couples to adopt children. The nuclear family exists in nature, but so does alpha male dominance in the family structure - and who would argue in favor of that in twenty-first century America?
Here’s the point (just when you were sure that I didn’t have one): there can be no law banning gay marriage that does not violate the First Amendment, and no judge who understands this terribly obvious premise and writes opinions based upon it can be thought of as activist anymore than he or she can be thought of as reasonable.
That America is so slow to accept this demonstrates just how slowly the sun of reason rises above the horizon of religion. We celebrate (if only to ourselves) when we read that this or that court has made it legal for gays to marry, and we do so because this is a big deal, a sign of progress. The real celebration will come when we read headlines like this and no longer think of them as a surprise.
Clearly the three dissenting judges were more liberal on the subject, but this might be a case where the more liberal position was not necessarily the best one. Did I really just say that? Yes, I did. And here’s why. One of the conservative positions on this issue has been their opposition to so-called activist judges who they fear will issue rulings that tend to favor gay marriage while ignoring the so-called will of the people. If the court had taken the action themselves, they would have opened themselves up to this kind of criticism from the right; by giving the responsibility back to the legislature, the court has given the people the opportunity to shape the law in a way that satisfies both the court and the people - should the people take this unique opportunity to see the light before it is forced upon their will by the court. The court has made a decision, but left the specifics of that decision up to the will of the people. Sounds like a good idea, but can the will of the people be trusted?
The will of people who have not spent their lives studying law and hearing cases and writing legal opinions, people who have no concept of what the separation of church and state really means, people who subscribe to the laws of the bible they claim to hold in such reverance only to the extent that those laws aren’t, you know, inconvenient to them in any way. The will of people, who, for example, once preferred that schools be segregated. The will of people who voted for George W. Bush the second time.
But let’s step aside from that argument for just a moment, even though it is sort of enjoyable. What, exactly, is the will of all these people? The will of these people is that gays not be allowed to marry.
Okay. Why not?
It’s just wrong.
Okay. Why?
Well...it’s just not natural.
Okay. Would you mind introducing me to all these inorganic gay people you know? I’d love to meet them. Are they like Data from Star Trek?
Well, I mean...it’s just wrong, isn’t it?
Sure it is. In the Bible. Homosexuality is wrong in the Bible, but it’s a protected class in the United States when it comes to just about everything except marriage and presiding over certain congregations (unless you’re really good at keeping secrets and can manage to train yourself only to blow the little altar boys you’re damn sure will keep their mouths shut about it). There are a lot of trespasses in the Bible, and a lot of things you are supposed to do if ye commit one of them unto your lord.
Of course, that’s all Old Testament nonsense. All of those Old Testament penalties were commuted down to one simple prayer in the New Testament; and even that is still nonsense, but now it’s nonsense that is a bit more expedient. It is far easier to utter a few Our Fathers than it is, say, to bring unto your lord a ram without blemish from the flock.
A quick glimpse at a few more of these “trespasses” reveals (skim the eleventh book of Leviticus if you doubt me here) that thou shalt not eat rabbit, pig, shrimp, scallop, oyster, clam, crab, lobster, squid, or octopus, owing to such arbitrary things as cud and scales and whatnot. And you can’t touch them if they’re dead, either, which isn’t a big thing - who really goes around groping dead seafood, apart from, say, fishers of men? - except for the fact that we loves us some football here in America (where we have, conveniently, perverted the term for a sport that the rest of the world loves and about which we know nothing, and have therefore dubbed soccer - and isn’t it odd that we use the term football to describe a game in which exactly two of the fifty-three players on each team ever get to touch the ball with their feet?) and gather round the telly every Sunday afternoon (probably this is a “trespass,” too, the day being Sunday and all) to watch a bunch of fellows compete to see which of their teams can score the most points by passing into the opposing team’s end zone (and doesn’t this act sound vaguely like sodomy, another of those “abominations?”) a ball made from the skin of a dead pig. Oh, and don’t forget that those fellows who are touching the carcass of that unclean, dead animal are doing so on the Sabbath, while on the clock. Better warm up the tar and feathers - or start gathering the stones for the stoning.
So...we have situational ethics and relativism with respect to the reading of Leviticus. It’s not okay for Moses to work on the Sabbath, but it is okay for Peyton Manning to do it. It’s not okay for Aaron to eat the unclean animal, but you go ahead and get that double pepperoni pizza with bacon. Fine. If you are religious, go ahead and apply the rule of your lord in any way you see fit; after all, you made up your day of judgment in the first place, so only you should be worried about having to answer for your hypocrisy when that day arrives. St. Peter’s interview of Pat Robertson alone is going to take a good two to three weeks.
But here’s where we trip another continental drift divide - you can’t apply that kind of biblical law to actions of the state, here meant to include government in any form at any level, from the Federal all the way down to local government at, say, the county level. Not without violating the First Amendment to the United States Constitution.
Marriage licenses are issued by the clerk of the county court. If a marriage license is refused to a gay couple, the refusal is based either on a law on the books (say, a state law prohibiting such at thing) or the biblical law that prohibits a man from lying with a man as he lies with a woman (Lev. 18:22) and vice versa, although, very technically, it’s not in there, which probably explains why people are more comfortable with lesbians than they are with gay men. Neither can hold without violating the First Amendment - the state law (or any statute at any level of government) goes back to the biblical law, and to uphold the biblical law in a governmental statute is tacit endorsement of the religion that expounds the law.
The problem, of course, even if you can get past the religious hypocrisy, is the idea of the nuclear family, which is the societal result of the embrace of marriage. People will say that the nuclear family is the cornerstone of society. Romantically, that is true; technically, it is not. Human beings are equipped with reason and speech, which separate them from the lower animals, and invest them with the ability to procreate in more ways than just having a fertile male mount a fertile woman and engage in intercourse at a particular time of the month until such time as the male has ejaculated millions of his little paddlers into the woman’s eager birth canal, into which it is hoped that a fertile egg shall descend in enough time to catch one of the intrepid little paddlers before he expires from the effort.
Such is the difference between humans - who conceived of sperm banks - and chimpanzees, who get it on outdoors and yet share better than 99% of their DNA with humans. It’s not illegal for unmarried women to have babies by artificial insemination; it’s not even illegal for gay couples to bear children this way; and it’s not illegal for gay couples to adopt children. The nuclear family exists in nature, but so does alpha male dominance in the family structure - and who would argue in favor of that in twenty-first century America?
Here’s the point (just when you were sure that I didn’t have one): there can be no law banning gay marriage that does not violate the First Amendment, and no judge who understands this terribly obvious premise and writes opinions based upon it can be thought of as activist anymore than he or she can be thought of as reasonable.
That America is so slow to accept this demonstrates just how slowly the sun of reason rises above the horizon of religion. We celebrate (if only to ourselves) when we read that this or that court has made it legal for gays to marry, and we do so because this is a big deal, a sign of progress. The real celebration will come when we read headlines like this and no longer think of them as a surprise.
Sunday, October 15, 2006
You're Naked Inside Your Fear
Okay, here we go. A second response to my anti-Statehouse-prayer letter, and this one accuses me of being anti-Christian. It’s printed in the Star on Sunday, October 15, 2006, and is authored by a human from Indianapolis. I shall refrain from calling him an idiot, although he is pretty close. He speaks about how atheist, Communist governments around the world treat the Christians in their midsts.
Hmm. I guess it depends on which resources you consult for your information on atheism. Of the five Communist countries remaining in existence (China, Cuba, Laos, North Korea, and Vietnam), the only one listed in the World Almanac for 2005 as officially atheist is China. Here are a few countries where Christianity is the primary religion, and where things have always been hunky-dory for the people: Germany, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda. Get the picture, Mr. ••••••••? Being mostly full of Christians does not automatically make a place good and its people fuzzy and lovable.
His second paragraph seems to suggest that religion is some sort of balm for suffering. He must be referring to such things as the Spanish Inquisition and the Crusades; and let's not forget the truly uplifting Salem witch trials. Freedom and democracy are the balms for suffering. Religion exists ONLY to explain what cannot be explained by the best mind currently living on earth. I can explain why Communism causes suffering, and that is because it teaches that each man must produce to the best of his ability so that the most needy and least productive of his fellow men can benefit from his efforts. This is the same as pouring light into a black hole - those who are able willingly sacrifice themselves to those who are unable; what will you do when the source of the light runs out? Write a new religious text? By what light will you operate your pen?
Our leaders must rely on wisdom from above? Oh my. And will it be you, Mr. ••••••••, who invalidates their degrees from Harvard and Yale and Stanford and Princeton? You who invalidates the firings of the synapses in their brains? By all means, let’s put it all on some invisible man in the sky.
What I am against, stated plainly in my letter, is having Christianity shoved down my throat by the majority of the people. Save it. You’re not going to get to me. And you shouldn’t be trying to get everyone else, either. The failure of the Old Testament as a sociological experiment proves that guilt as a weapon is an intractable premise.
I am perfectly tolerant of Christians. My wife is a Christian, and she is the most tolerant and amazing human being I have ever known. She does not shove it down my throat; she does not ask me to go to to church with her (too often); she does not castigate me for taking her lord’s name in vain; she does not judge me. She does think I am overzealous sometimes. Wonder how she came to that conclusion. It's an uphill battle for the free-thinking in this state.
Religion has two places, for those who feel compelled, for reasons passing understanding, to buy into it - in church, and in the home. It does not, can not, belong in the public discourse. The reason for this is that there are so many different religions out there that the public discourse simply does not have room for all of them. Who is to say which mythology is right and which is wrong? Who can judge? Who has that right? To accept them equally is to strip them each of their superiority, and this is where the religious show their fear. It is why they cannot be trusted. They are not truly convinced they are right, but they are terrified that they are wrong.
The only reason that religion exists is because there are people who acknowledge the power that fear has over their senses and their reason. This is the final hurdle, to overcome that fear and believe in your reason.
It has nothing to do with tolerance, apart from the fact that there are some who tolerate their fear of existing as free humans on planet earth. You live and you die. It’s okay. So does everyone else.
Hmm. I guess it depends on which resources you consult for your information on atheism. Of the five Communist countries remaining in existence (China, Cuba, Laos, North Korea, and Vietnam), the only one listed in the World Almanac for 2005 as officially atheist is China. Here are a few countries where Christianity is the primary religion, and where things have always been hunky-dory for the people: Germany, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda. Get the picture, Mr. ••••••••? Being mostly full of Christians does not automatically make a place good and its people fuzzy and lovable.
His second paragraph seems to suggest that religion is some sort of balm for suffering. He must be referring to such things as the Spanish Inquisition and the Crusades; and let's not forget the truly uplifting Salem witch trials. Freedom and democracy are the balms for suffering. Religion exists ONLY to explain what cannot be explained by the best mind currently living on earth. I can explain why Communism causes suffering, and that is because it teaches that each man must produce to the best of his ability so that the most needy and least productive of his fellow men can benefit from his efforts. This is the same as pouring light into a black hole - those who are able willingly sacrifice themselves to those who are unable; what will you do when the source of the light runs out? Write a new religious text? By what light will you operate your pen?
Our leaders must rely on wisdom from above? Oh my. And will it be you, Mr. ••••••••, who invalidates their degrees from Harvard and Yale and Stanford and Princeton? You who invalidates the firings of the synapses in their brains? By all means, let’s put it all on some invisible man in the sky.
What I am against, stated plainly in my letter, is having Christianity shoved down my throat by the majority of the people. Save it. You’re not going to get to me. And you shouldn’t be trying to get everyone else, either. The failure of the Old Testament as a sociological experiment proves that guilt as a weapon is an intractable premise.
I am perfectly tolerant of Christians. My wife is a Christian, and she is the most tolerant and amazing human being I have ever known. She does not shove it down my throat; she does not ask me to go to to church with her (too often); she does not castigate me for taking her lord’s name in vain; she does not judge me. She does think I am overzealous sometimes. Wonder how she came to that conclusion. It's an uphill battle for the free-thinking in this state.
Religion has two places, for those who feel compelled, for reasons passing understanding, to buy into it - in church, and in the home. It does not, can not, belong in the public discourse. The reason for this is that there are so many different religions out there that the public discourse simply does not have room for all of them. Who is to say which mythology is right and which is wrong? Who can judge? Who has that right? To accept them equally is to strip them each of their superiority, and this is where the religious show their fear. It is why they cannot be trusted. They are not truly convinced they are right, but they are terrified that they are wrong.
The only reason that religion exists is because there are people who acknowledge the power that fear has over their senses and their reason. This is the final hurdle, to overcome that fear and believe in your reason.
It has nothing to do with tolerance, apart from the fact that there are some who tolerate their fear of existing as free humans on planet earth. You live and you die. It’s okay. So does everyone else.
Thursday, October 12, 2006
You Symbiotic, Patriotic Slam But Neck, Right?
Right.
The other night I tripped a nice continental drift divide and decided to write a letter to the editor of the Indianapolis Star, in response to a human who had written a letter praising Indiana House Speaker Brian Bosma for working hard to reinstate a daily prayer to begin each session of business in the Statehouse. The letter-writer praised the tradition of prayer to open business in the Statehouse, and I questioned the need for that tradition. Here’s the letter (the Star edited the version they printed; this is the unedited version):
“In response to Bryan Hollingsworth's letter praising Speaker Bosma for upholding the tradition of prayer to open daily business in the Statehouse: Why is the tradition even necessary? Why do the religious feel so threatened when more well-reasoned elements in the social strata begin to marginalize religion in the public discourse? Such is the way with all superstitions; eventually, reason kicks in and the superstition is discarded. The people who are indignant about this and want prayer in the Statehouse are Christians who want Christian prayer in the Statehouse. If it were a daily prayer to Allah and a recitation from the Qur’an, there would be an outcry; if the daily prayer were a Shinto or Buddhist or Hindu prayer, there were would be an outcry. This is not about the expression of religion; it is about the continued dominance of Christianity in the public discourse. There is no majority rule in public policy with respect to religion; Christians do not get to sit at the front of the bus just because there are more of them, and they do not get to pray to their alleged savior in the arena of public policy. Science every day opens our eyes a little wider to the idea that we no longer require the crutch of religion, and every day explains more of the previously inexplicable, thereby making religion less relevant. It seems as though the true believers are terrified that religion will one day be outlawed. The Constitution forbids that, however. The Founding Fathers understood that religion was important to some people, but they also understood that it should not be thrust upon everyone.”
Today, there was a letter in the Star responding to my letter. A human from Greenwood suggested that I go to Washington, D.C., to see all the inscriptions of Christian faith in all the big government buildings. These inscriptions in Washington, she intimates, prove the grounds upon which this country was founded. Okay. Except that the word “God,” whether with a capital-G or otherwise, does not appear in the United States Constitution. Neither do the words “Jesus,” “Christ,” “creator,” “creation,” “religion,” or “religious.” The word “created” appears once in the Constitution. Article I, Section 6, Paragraph 2, says that no member of Congress will be allowed to hold civil office while also serving in Congress, regardless of whether that civil office be already in existence or newly created while the Congressman is serving. None of those words appear in the Bill of Rights; and they do not appear in any of the Amendments that follow the tenth. The values present in the law of the land may have been influenced by Christianity, but the Founding Fathers stripped all mention of it out of the written law.
Oh, and they founded our country in Philadelphia, not Washington. But, you know, the religious don’t put much store in the facts. They just point at their Bibles and say it’s in there, somewhere.
This was my whole point - today’s letter-writer seems to have missed most of it. She positively insists that this is a Christian place, these United States of America; and that is incorrect, because majority rule does not apply to a population based on how many of them adhere (however loosely) to a particular faith. I mentioned that in my letter, but the Star chose to excise that part of it. This is a country made up mostly of Christians, but it is not a Christian country. It’s a fine line, to be sure; but it’s a line that is there. A truly free country cannot be categorized by the faith of its people; to do so would invalidate the freedom. Here is my response to her response to me:
“If I may respond to Ms. ••••••, I would ask why it would be necessary for me to go to Washington in order to be inundated by her religion. I live in Indiana, where it almost feels as though one were drowing in Jesus with virtually no hope of catching even a glimpse of the life preserver of reason. The United States of America is not a Christian country. It is just a country. There is no majority rule with respect to religion; at least, there is no majority rule with respect to religion in a free country. If it were true that majority rule made this a Christian country, it would no longer be free. And it would no longer be worth living in.”
Most of what is in that response I have already mentioned in this post, but I wanted to share the letter as I submitted it to the Star, for posterity, or whatever. So that the handful of you who read this will know what I really said, if the Star prints something different. Uh...yeah. I send an echo now to the reasoned: Is there anybody out there?
The other night I tripped a nice continental drift divide and decided to write a letter to the editor of the Indianapolis Star, in response to a human who had written a letter praising Indiana House Speaker Brian Bosma for working hard to reinstate a daily prayer to begin each session of business in the Statehouse. The letter-writer praised the tradition of prayer to open business in the Statehouse, and I questioned the need for that tradition. Here’s the letter (the Star edited the version they printed; this is the unedited version):
“In response to Bryan Hollingsworth's letter praising Speaker Bosma for upholding the tradition of prayer to open daily business in the Statehouse: Why is the tradition even necessary? Why do the religious feel so threatened when more well-reasoned elements in the social strata begin to marginalize religion in the public discourse? Such is the way with all superstitions; eventually, reason kicks in and the superstition is discarded. The people who are indignant about this and want prayer in the Statehouse are Christians who want Christian prayer in the Statehouse. If it were a daily prayer to Allah and a recitation from the Qur’an, there would be an outcry; if the daily prayer were a Shinto or Buddhist or Hindu prayer, there were would be an outcry. This is not about the expression of religion; it is about the continued dominance of Christianity in the public discourse. There is no majority rule in public policy with respect to religion; Christians do not get to sit at the front of the bus just because there are more of them, and they do not get to pray to their alleged savior in the arena of public policy. Science every day opens our eyes a little wider to the idea that we no longer require the crutch of religion, and every day explains more of the previously inexplicable, thereby making religion less relevant. It seems as though the true believers are terrified that religion will one day be outlawed. The Constitution forbids that, however. The Founding Fathers understood that religion was important to some people, but they also understood that it should not be thrust upon everyone.”
Today, there was a letter in the Star responding to my letter. A human from Greenwood suggested that I go to Washington, D.C., to see all the inscriptions of Christian faith in all the big government buildings. These inscriptions in Washington, she intimates, prove the grounds upon which this country was founded. Okay. Except that the word “God,” whether with a capital-G or otherwise, does not appear in the United States Constitution. Neither do the words “Jesus,” “Christ,” “creator,” “creation,” “religion,” or “religious.” The word “created” appears once in the Constitution. Article I, Section 6, Paragraph 2, says that no member of Congress will be allowed to hold civil office while also serving in Congress, regardless of whether that civil office be already in existence or newly created while the Congressman is serving. None of those words appear in the Bill of Rights; and they do not appear in any of the Amendments that follow the tenth. The values present in the law of the land may have been influenced by Christianity, but the Founding Fathers stripped all mention of it out of the written law.
Oh, and they founded our country in Philadelphia, not Washington. But, you know, the religious don’t put much store in the facts. They just point at their Bibles and say it’s in there, somewhere.
This was my whole point - today’s letter-writer seems to have missed most of it. She positively insists that this is a Christian place, these United States of America; and that is incorrect, because majority rule does not apply to a population based on how many of them adhere (however loosely) to a particular faith. I mentioned that in my letter, but the Star chose to excise that part of it. This is a country made up mostly of Christians, but it is not a Christian country. It’s a fine line, to be sure; but it’s a line that is there. A truly free country cannot be categorized by the faith of its people; to do so would invalidate the freedom. Here is my response to her response to me:
“If I may respond to Ms. ••••••, I would ask why it would be necessary for me to go to Washington in order to be inundated by her religion. I live in Indiana, where it almost feels as though one were drowing in Jesus with virtually no hope of catching even a glimpse of the life preserver of reason. The United States of America is not a Christian country. It is just a country. There is no majority rule with respect to religion; at least, there is no majority rule with respect to religion in a free country. If it were true that majority rule made this a Christian country, it would no longer be free. And it would no longer be worth living in.”
Most of what is in that response I have already mentioned in this post, but I wanted to share the letter as I submitted it to the Star, for posterity, or whatever. So that the handful of you who read this will know what I really said, if the Star prints something different. Uh...yeah. I send an echo now to the reasoned: Is there anybody out there?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)