Showing posts with label Kismetic Beer Company. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kismetic Beer Company. Show all posts

Sunday, June 14, 2026

630. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - My Dog’s From Denver

“Collaboration beer brewed by more than 13 local Indiana breweries. Featuring El Dorado and Chinook hops with a touch of Cascade. 6% of sales are donated to FACE animal clinic.”

UPDATE - 6/14/26
Finally located this beer in cans today, at the new Sahm’s joint called Big Lug Filling Station, which took over the space that used to be Garfield Brewery. The label on the can lists all 13 breweries that were involved in the collaboration, which is a nice touch. Hopefully the verbiage on the label that says, “A Truly Local Collaborative Series” means that these cats will get together again and produce something just as good as this one.


This is a new 7.4% American Pale Ale that they have just tapped, and it’s the first beer I can remember having here that has a name. It’s definitely one of the biggest beers they have ever served. Smooth and caramelly up front, with a slightly bitter finish that holds up through the first several sips. There’s a vaguely fruity flavor that might be cherries or almonds, and the overall flavor might be what is so often bandied about as “dank.” The bitter finish softens a bit as the beer warms, but the fruit stays just out of arm’s length. With 12 other hands in the mix, though, no way to know how much of this is Ryan; but it’s one of the best beers I’ve ever had here, though not my favorite.

Thursday, May 14, 2026

636. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Barrel-Aged Coffee Porter

So they haven’t posted this on their website yet, so I can’t give a description. I tried one tonight at the taproom, and it was very good. It’s dusted with something that smells like nutmeg, and there’s a big bite of alcohol up front on the first sip. Some whisky flavor from the barrel, but it’s not overpowering; and it’s very lightly carbonated. Not much coffee flavor, but there is a dry hint on the back end that could be coffee, or chocolate malt. It’s an excellent beer, and I am looking forward to the next one.

Tuesday, August 05, 2025

616. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Oatmeal Stout

“Stout, although one of my favorite styles to drink, is rarely on my brewing schedule. That is about to change. Inspired by a conversation with the team [at Fort George Brewing], we decided to do a series of stout and really explore what the style has to offer. This first offering is brewed with 2-row barley, Caramunich, Carafa Special 1 and 3, Midnight wheat, and rye. Hopped with Magnum and Hersbrucker. Mashed hot with an extended 2 hour boil. Aromas of toffee and dark fruits, with notes of coffee and chocolate. Rich and full on the palate, with sweet caramel and cocoa covered raisin notes balanced by a dry and roasty finish.”

I had a hard time making up my mind about this one. It doesn’t have the smooth mouthfeel up front that I have come to associate with oatmeal stouts, and the overall body of the beer is not as rich as same. But it’s growing on me. There are roasty chocolate malt elements and hints of dried fruit; and it does react well to being able to warm up and breathe a little bit. The style is perhaps not Ryan’s strong suit, but he still makes a pretty good one.

Sunday, February 16, 2025

613. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Watermelon Mint Gose

“Our take on a gose-style kettle sour, with additions of pink sea salt, and both cold and hot steepings of Nelson’s Tea Watermelon Mint rooibos blend. Notes of mint and tropical fruit on the nose, sour and herbal, salty and refreshing.”

Moderate flavor of herbal mint up front, with just a hint of watermelon, and a light sour taste. As the beer warms, the watermelon flavor becomes a little more pronounced and the mint gets a bit lighter. Sours are definitely one of Ryan’s strong suits, and this one might well be the best of the lot.

Sunday, December 22, 2024

607. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Orange Plum Sour with Lavender

“A new take on our sour. Brewed with Montana pilsner, white wheat and flaked wheat. Steeped with a blend of lavender and orange peel, fruited with plum. Lightly herbal on the nose, with notes of citrus and stone fruit. Bright sourness balanced on the palate with rich plum and sweet clementines.”

I’m getting a strong floral aroma on the nose, with light orange and stone fruit flavor up front. The stone fruit lingers on the back end quite pleasantly, and there is just the barest hint of sour. Ryan has a real knack for brewing sours that are sour without also being a kick in the nuts. He is easily the most gifted brewer I have encountered since I discovered Dan Gayle’s beers at Black Circle. Nothing Ryan brews is disappointing, even styles I don’t usually dig very much. I really can’t say enough about this place, nor about Nicole and Ryan. (Go on a weekend sometime, when one of them is pulling handles behind the bar. Listen to them talk. That’s what the proprietor of your local watering hole is supposed to sound like.)

Thursday, September 19, 2024

605. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Banana Nut Bread Hefeweizen

“A hefeweizen style wheat beer, hot and cold steeped with Nelson’s Tea Banana Nut Bread rooibos tea blead [sic], rich and bready, with notes of ripe bananas and walnuts.”

Very bready up front, with a hint of chalky walnut and a smooth, soft finish. A little bit of banana flavor lingers, and this batch has less baking spice flavor than the previous batches. Still very good, but if I didn’t know this was the banana nut bread version, I might not have guessed.

604. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Amaro Saison

“Our version of an Aperol Spritz. Brewed with 6 row barley, pale ale, Caramunich, white wheat, and rye. Hopped with Magnum and Lotus. Cold and hot steeped with gentian, chinchona, grapefruit peel, lemon peel, orange peel, rose hips, orris, grains of paradise, chamomile, fennel, star anise, black pepper and a few other spices. Aromas of black licorice and spicy phenolic, balanced with flavors of bubblegum, pepper, and Good and Plenty’s [sic]. For the fans of amaro, herbal liqueurs, or even an Underberg.”

Minty aroma and a minty, spicy taste up front that drifts into a pleasantly bitter finish that smooths out as the beer warms. Possibly some grapefruit pith in there contributing to the bitter finish, and then bright orange flavor as the bitterness smooths. Even more complex and spectacular than the Marzen. (And much like with the Cold IPA, I may have to update this post after I have tried a second one.

Saturday, September 14, 2024

603. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Cold IPA

“Our take on a new style out of Oregon. Described by the originator as more West Coast than West Coast, this IPA is brewed with America pilsner, Vienna, and flaked rice. Hopped with Azacca, Apollo, and Amarillo. It is fermented with lager yeast at ale temps. It is dry hopped at the tail end of fermentation to achieve some fruit forward bio tranformation [sic]. Crisp and dry, with aromas of pine and citrus, bitter and crisp on the palate.”

Piney aroma and taste up front. Dry finish. Any fruit in there does not assert itself in the first couple of sips, but turns into a slight citrus shine as the beer warms. There’s a fresh, herbal taste that eventually comes up and makes me think of fresh fruit that isn’t quite ripe yet. Also excellent, but I’m too inured to IPAs. I will try this one again and may update the post.

602. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Marzen

“Brewed with Munich, Vienna, Caramunich, rye and chit. Hopped with Magnum and Sazz. We went as traditional as we could and brewed in March and then lagered for 6 months. Bready and rich, with notes of toffee and brioche on the nose. Sweet malty complexity is balanced by a firm, bitter backbone.”

It’s got a light roasty taste up front, with a dry finish that smooths out and begins to feel more like the light spice of rye about halfway through. A little bit of caramel floats around almost playfully, but never quite asserts itself. There might be a hint of dried fruit in there, too—especially on the nose. Full and complex, but not heavy. Spectacular.

Sunday, October 22, 2023

585. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Pumpkin Ale

“We started with sugar pie pumpkins that we roasted with a brown sugar simple syrup and a pumpkin spice blend. We added the roast pumpkin to a mash bill of Maris Otter, Munich, Caramunich, and Chocolate malts. Hopped with Magnum. Steeped with Tahitian, Madagascar, and Mexican vanilla beans, Ceylon cinnamon, and Penzey’s pumpkin pie spice blend. Rich, but balanced, aromas of spices and caramel, creamy with lingering, crisp finish.”

Nice balance of pumpkin and spice flavors up front, with some lingering vanilla and caramel on the back end. Like most of Ryan’s beer, this one is flavorful and complex at the same that it’s light and drinkable.

Monday, July 03, 2023

559. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Lemon Cream Earl Grey American Wheat Ale

“Brewed for these hot summer days, we hot and cold steeped this light wheat beer with Nelson Tea’s Lemon Cream Earl Gray blend. Aromas of yeasty funk combine with light herbal and citrus notes, as well as subtle flavors of lemon, cream and spicy bergamot to round out this light summer sipper.”

That must be the Earl Grey that I’m tasting big and floral up front. The lemon cream comes in right on the heels of that, and then the bergamot lingers into the pleasantly dry finish. There’s so much flavor going on that you don’t even notice the fact that it’s only 4.7% ABV—which is what Ryan’s beers are all about. It’s also a testament to the quality of Nelson Teas; I can’t imagine that it’s a coincidence that this and the Banana Nut Bread Hefeweizen (also brewed with Nelson Teas) are two of the best things I have had at Kismetic.

Saturday, May 20, 2023

540. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Post. Cold IPA

“Collaboration with Pax Verum for the 2023 Post. Music Festival! Cold IPA brewed with Magnum, Simcoe, Strata & Belma hops.”

I had a sample of this last night at Kismetic, and that sample tasted strongly of grass and herbs, with a classic “hoppy” flavor up front, and some light floral notes that lingered on the palate. The full pint I had tonight at Kismetic almost tasted like a different beer. It was lighter and fruitier, with a dry, rather than bitter, finish. This is also, as far as I know, the first beer from Kismetic that has been available in cans for carry-out. The one out of the can tasted like the ones I had in the taproom tonight—light and fruity, with a dry finish. The 6.9% ABV is a little high for one of Ryan’s joints, but it doesn’t drink like it’s that big. I wish that the ones I tried today had more of the earthy flavor that last night’s sample had, but it’s still a pretty good beer.

Sunday, April 02, 2023

530. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - Hoppy Irish Red

“This take on an Irish Red was inspired by the Pink Boots hop blend from Yakima Chief. We began with a rich malt base of Maris Otter, some Caramunich and Carafa for caramel and color, and a hefty dose of Rye for some spice. Loral, Ekuanot, and HBC 586 in the hop blend add notes of citrus and herbal, woodsy spice. Malty and nutty, with flavors of bright clementine and pine. This beer was brewed by women from all around the Indy beer industry, and a portion of all pints sold will be donated to our local Pink Boots chapter to help fund education opportunities for our members!”

Beautifully complex, this beer starts out roasty and smoky and then comes in fruity and hoppy (with a touch of caramel) on the back end as it warms up. The second one, one day later, is slightly more fruity—but still malty and smoky and roasty. Very fine.

529. Kismetic Beer Company (Indianapolis, IN) - New England IPA

“Lotus, Amarillo, and Mandarina Bavaria combine to offer aromas of sweet clementine and tropical fruits. Pale ale malt base with flaked oats, flaked wheat, and wheat keep the body creamy and rich.”

This is my new favorite place to go after work to write for an hour and drink two beers. I want to like the new Scarlet Lane, where Black Acre used to be, but I don’t yet. This place has a nice vibe, vaguely kitschy post-modern art-deco decor, and some very fine low-ABV beers. This one has a nice haze to it, and very light orange flavors up front, before a very fine dry finish. I’m not sure I get the smooth taste of the oat in the grain profile, but the two I have had have poured very cold, so that might have something to do with it. Ryan’s shtick is low ABV, so IPAs might be somewhat outside of his wheelhouse—but this is not bad. (It also ain’t great, but it is pleasant and very drinkable.)